• Home
  • Subscribe
  • Donate to Tikun Olam
  • Comment Rules
  • Contact
  • About

Tikun Olam תיקון עולם

Breaking news on the Israeli national security state

Featured Post

Democracy, Theocracy and Rushdie The apocalyptic struggle between adherents of democracy and theocracy is a zero-sum game

August 14, 2022 By Richard Silverstein 2 Comments

The attack on Salman Rushdie has shaken many of us to our core for many reasons. First, though religious and ethnic hate has become endemic in American society, we pride ourselves on insulating America from the age-old hatreds of the Old World.  Second, our law enforcement institutions have done a relatively good job in protecting us from those who sought to import these hatreds to our shores.  Third, as a largely secular society, we have rarely suffered from, or understood the fury of these ancient religious hatreds.

The attempted murderer, Hadi Matar, is the son of south Lebanese refugees who emigrated to the US, where he was born. South Lebanon is a Shia stronghold dominated by Hezbollah.  The latter is closely allied with Iran, which has supplied it with much of the weaponry and expertise used to defend Lebanon from Israeli aggression.  Hezbollah also shipped thousands of its fighters to Syria to prop up the Assad regime, also closely allied with Iran.

It isn’t known whether Matar acted alone or whether he was part of a larger conspiracy involving Lebanese-Hezbollah elements.  If so, any implication of Hezbollah or Iranian involvement would be catastrophic for both.  But especially for Iran.  If it were proven that Iran played any direct or indirect part, the negotiation for the JCPOA agreement would come to a screeching halt.  Whatever thin bit of credibility Iran had among foreign nations would be forfeit.

Though I’m inclined to believe he was a lone wolf terrorist; on the other hand, tracking a target, let alone all the surveillance and planning that must go into preparing such an attack might indicate a wider conspiracy.

We like to think in this country that the gradual absorption and assimilation of immigrants turns them into Americans, and lessens the intensity of ethnic-religious extremism  This, after all, is the path that most immigrant groups have taken within American society, including Jews who fled Europe in the 19th and 20th centuries.  It has been rare, till now, to see immigrant groups willing to spill blood here in order to enforce their orthodoxy.

This post will not delve into the specifics of the Khomeini fatwa or Rushdie’s novel, Satanic Verses, which inspired it.  Clearly, I personally strongly object to any such infringement on artistic freedom and free speech.  Thus, it goes without saying that the attack on Rushdie was heinous and inexcusable.

Democracy, Theocracy: the Zero-Sum Game

But in broader terms, I am alarmed at the clash between fundamentalist extremists and democratic essentialists.  Both sides see the fight as a “clash of civilizations” (to use a more essentialist term) in which there can be no compromise.  Democracy advocates are no less fervent in their view that Islam is a dark, primitive religion with traditions best left in the Middle Ages.  They believe there is no room for anything but democracy; while Islamists view secularism as a mortal enemy.

This explains the origin of the Iranian fatwa and so much of the hatred Iranian ayatollahs project on the west (not without justification, considering the history).  But it also explains the zeal with which Bush and Cheney prosecuted the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.  They believed that they offered an opportunity to “spread democracy” to Middle Eastern societies. This implies that Middle Eastern societies are backward and in need of western “uplift.”  Similarly, western attempts to de-radicalize Muslim youth, as the UK PREVENT program attempted to do, are doomed to failure because they attempt to “convert” Muslims from one religion to another (secularism).  Both perspectives are misguided.  Both have led to decades of bloodshed and unending hatred.

The rigid stance of certain Islamist strains and the missionary ardor of the west must not become zero-sum games.  Humanity is at its most ugly and brutal when absolutism is the predominant force in society.  Hundreds of millions have died on the altar of fanaticism, whether Nazi, Stalinist or Christian.

In this sense, both warring parties are talking past each other.  When Rushdie and his allies talk about a “freedom to offend,” they are attempting to impose a western value on the debate.  On the other hand, religious believers, by their very nature, demand absolute fealty to their doctrine.  Offending it is offending God.  And when Islamists cheer the attack, saying Rushdie is “Satan on a path to hell,” they too seek to impose their absolutist doctrine on all.  This is a recipe for eternal conflict.

We need to find a path that embraces humility and tolerance.  The latter does not mean acceptance of a code conflicting with our own.  We are no less devout in our beliefs when we allow for divergent views.  But it also means we must turn away from a doctrinal triumphalism which affirms the supremacy of western democracy or Middle Eastern religious traditions.

Israeli NGOs Call for Sanctions Against Israel During Gaza Attack Israeli human rights groups call for UN sanctions against Israel

August 14, 2022

Amidst the Israeli back-slapping over the “success” of its attack on Gaza, in which the IDF murdered 49 Palestinians, over half women and children, a groundbreaking protest by Israeli human rights NGOs passed almost unnoticed.  The cause of human rights causes barely a ripple in Israeli society, which is deeply implicated in war crimes and […]

Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: No Solutions, No Illusions Today, there is no solution. Only illusion.

August 10, 2022

Is there a solution to the conflict? I would argue, no.  Forever? No.  But for now, there is no reasonable chance to reach such a solution.  Has there been a chance over the past 70 years? No.  For the next 70 years? Maybe. This is a tough thing to admit for someone who’s been devoted […]

Israel Assassinates Senior Islamic Jihad Gaza Commanders, 600 Rockets Fired at Israel 44 Gazans murdered, including 15 children, as ceasefire takes effect

August 6, 2022

UPDATE: Egypt has brokered what’s being called a ceasefire between Israel and Islamic Jihad, which has cost the lives of 32 Palestinians, with no cost whatsover to Israelis. It’s a so-called ceasefire because there is no such thing as far as Israel is concerned.  It violates ceasefires at its pleasure. It agrees to ceasefires when […]

Aipac Pumps $30-Million into Democratic Primaries to Defeat Israel Critics Israel Lobby poisons democracy by buying elections

August 5, 2022

A funny thing happened to Bernie Sanders on the way to the 2020 Iowa presidential caucus.  That state is the first real race in the nomination process, and a critical opportunity for candidates to make their mark before Democratic voters.  Sanders was doing well in the polls and appeared he might even win.  This sent […]

  • Palestinian refugee, 1948 (from "Censored Voices")
  • Nakba: grandaughter and grandfather
  • Neve Shalom, Dove of Peace
  • Jerusalem Hope, Palestine Poster Collection
  • Offering Reconciliation, Parent's Circle exhibition
  • Mohammed Said Kalash bowl, Offering Reconciliation, Parent's Circle
  • Tsilya Aguf, Ukraine 1930s (Centropa)
  • Ketubah, Iran
  • Shushan Machzor (New York Public Library)
  • Mishneh Torah Maimonides
  • Sarajevo Haggadah
  • Sarajevo Haggadah, Mah Nishtanah
  • Bibi Netanyahu (Vanity Fair)
  • Naftali Bennett, Lebanon war criminal: "I've killed many Arabs."
  • The [Sabra] Hulk (Mysh )
  • A Problem of Self Image (Mysh )
  • "Promises," Israeli & Palestinian Boy
  • menachem froman
    Rabbi Menachem Froman z"l (Rina Castelnuovo)
  • Rabbi Menachem Froman z"l & Palestinian Imam
  • Great Day on Eldrige Street, Klezmer musicians
  • Yale Strom, Eldridge Street shul
  • Eldridge Street Shul
  • Besa Albanian-Muslim Righteous Gentile (Norman Gershman)
  • Daniel Barenboim, West-Eastern Diwan Orchestra
  • Hebron Palestinian in IDF gunsight (Breaking the Silence)
  • Archipelago of Palestine
  • Bedouin: I am Invisible
  • East Jerusalem shouk
  • Balian Armenian ceramics, Olive Tree
  • Jerusalem pottery, 1972
  • Balian ceramics, Jerusalem
  • Dancing Gazelles Balian Ceramics
  • Balian Armenian ceramics, Jerusalem (2004)
  • Balian ceramics, East Jerusalem
  • Pincus and the Pig: a Klezmer Tale
  • Im Tirzu: a Fascist Movement
  • Marcy Silverstein (grandfather) and semi-pro baseball team circa 1920
  • Pete Seeger & Bruce Springsteen, 'This Land is Your Land' (Justin Sullivan/ Getty)
  • Leonard Baskin: Ruth and Naomi, "Five Scrolls"
  • Ben Shahn, "You Have Not Converted a Man"
  • Study for Goyescas, Ben Shahn
  • Allegory, Ben Shahn
  • The Phoenix, Ben Shahn
  • Ben Shahn Ecclesiastes
  • Ben Shahn Warsaw 1943, Martyrology, "These I Remember"
  • Ben Shahn's Haggadah
  • Black Lives Matter, Seattle
  • Shavuot papercut, Poland
  • Hamsa with Star of David
  • Quran, Turkey, 19th century
  • Harriet Tubman, I Go To Prepare A Place For You (detail), Bisa Butler, 2021
  • Arboretum 2015
  • Arboretum fall color
  • Fall color, Washinton Park Arboretum, Seattle
  • Rhododenrons, Washington Park Arboretum
  • Gee's Bend African-American quilt
  • Gee's Bend quilt, Ana Mae Young
  • Gee's Bend quilt
  • Gee's Bend quilt, stripes
  • Gee's Bend box quilt
  • Gee's Bend quilt, stars
  • Gee's Bend quilt
  • Gee's Bend quilt, flags
  • Armenia-Palestine: We will mourn with you. (WATAN)
  • Washington Arboretum, frozen pond fall leaves
  • New Jewish Agenda, Celebrate People's History
  • Mt. Ranier
  • Mosque celing, Iran
  • tomb of esther and mordechai
    Tomb of Esther and Mordechai, Hamadan (Iran)
  • Mosque ceiling, Qom Iran
  • Palestinian embroidery, Bethlehem
  • Palestine embroidered
  • Tatreez Institute (Wafa Ghnaim)
  • Palestinian embroidery
  • Palestinian Floral Thobe (WATAN)
  • Palestinian child's quilt
  • Tatreez Institute (Wafa Ghnaim)
  • Palestinian dolls YWCA Jerusalem
  • Fabric of Our Lives, YWCA of Palestine
  • Palestinian thobe
  • Palestinian embroidery, Bethlehem
  • Chagall window, Hadassha Hospital chapel
  • Mosque ceiling, Iran
  • Shah-e-Cheragh Shrine, Shiraz
  • Golestan palace, Iran
  • Golestan Palace, Tehran (photo: M. Ganji)
  • Timche-Ye Amin Od-Dowleh, Kashan (photo: M. Ganji)
  • Ramallah nursing students take a lunch break. (Tanya Habjouqa)
  • The Gaza Parkour & Free Running team practice in a Khan Younis cemetery, Gaza. (Tanya Habjouqa)
  • Toy delivery van on Gaza Beach Highway. (Tanya Habjouqa)
  • Mt. Rainer from Sunrise Trail

Support Tikun Olam (tax-deductible)

Recent Posts

  • Democracy, Theocracy and Rushdie
  • Israeli NGOs Call for Sanctions Against Israel
  • Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: No Solutions, No Illusions
  • Israel Assassinates Senior Islamic Jihad Gaza Commanders, 600 Rockets Fired at Israel
  • Aipac Pumps $30-Million into Democratic Primaries to Defeat Israel Critics

Search

Categories

Archives

Pages

  • Photo Gallery
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Publications (author page)

  • Middle East Eye
  • The Nation Magazine
  • Al Jazeera
  • Jacobin
  • New Arab
  • Comment is Free
  • Mint Press News
  • Truthout
  • Seattle Times

Mideast Peace

  • Rebuilding Alliance
  • Human Rights Defenders
  • Cafe Tel Aviv
  • Encounter Programs
  • Just Vision
  • Palestine Deep Dive
  • Negev Co-Existence Forum
  • Open Hillel
  • Levantine Center
  • Jewish Voice for Peace

Progressive Media

  • Contrary Perspective
  • Scheer Post
  • Challenging Christian Zionism
  • Jewish Voice for Labour
  • Vashti Media
  • Canadian Dimension
  • Global Voices

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Tikun Olam is fiscally sponsored by Media Alliance, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization.

Be a Mensch: Support Tikun Olam!

Thanks for visiting Tikun Olam. It breaks exclusive stories on Israel-Palestine, often not yet published anywhere, including Israel. Please subscribe to new posts–and tell all your friends!

Support my unique work with a tax-deductible donation to Media Alliance, my fiscal sponsor.