11 thoughts on “Yossi Melman: Barak-Haaretz Claims About New Iranian Nuclear Advances Disputed – Tikun Olam תיקון עולם إصلاح العالم
Comments are published at the sole discretion of the owner.

  1. Something like this has never happened…that secret intelligence would be revealed either deliberately or unintentionally to the media.

    Hahahaha! Was there nobody to laugh this “American official”, no doubt granted anonymity because he “wasn’t authorised to speak with the media”, out of the room?

  2. Richard. Just recently, you took this “veteran Israeli intelligence correspondent” to the woodshed.

    You wrote:

    “Melman and his co-author, Newsweek reporter Dan Raviv, have done the fantasists one better: he’s taken an ounce of truth and added a pound of unsubstantiated claims and put it between two covers and offered it to a gullible world hungry to hear the heroic exploits of the Ari Ben Canaans of the Israeli spy service”.

    So today, when it suits, Melman’s reportage is the ’emeth’.

    1. Yes, believe it or not there might be a statement you might make that I’d credit as accurate. It wouldn’t happen often, but it’s possible I would. Same thing with Melman. I judge people based on what I know & comparing it to what they write. If they’re wrong I respond accordingly. If they’re right, I respond accordingly. That may be a little too nuanced for your black & white world, but so be it.

  3. So as everybody on the planet already knows, and Yossi Melman is forced to accept to have any credibility at all in the future, that Ehud Barak and Bibi Netanyahu are actively hoaxing the US into war with Iran

    How many bites at the apple to these liars get until the sheer weight of their lies and threats causes a miscalculation or Iranian response, which Barak and Bibi can then jump of as incontrovertable truth that Iran is evil/a terrorist state/fighting back? It’s a set-up, a con job, a scam

    The Israelis are once again manufacturing a scenario where SOMETHING they can use eventually pops up as sheer probabilities of chance alone – they’re just setting up a duck that they can then knock down.

    It’s a fools game to let them run a scam like this – year after year – instead of just stopping them and stopping them cold.

    Israel is a clear and present danger to the security of the United States as an Israeli attack on Iran will destroy the American economy, LET ALONE dragging the US into the war itself. As such a NO FLY ZONE should be set up around Israel and any Israel jet trying to overfly Turkey, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt or Iraq challenged and if not forced back then forced down.

    Instead of Turkey sending Stingers to Syria – the US should be sending Stingers and advanced Patriot batteries to all the nations above, along with S300/S400 Russian antiaircraft missiles to Iran and Syria to PREVENT and if necessary STOP an Israeli attack on Iran

    1. @bluto
      sure, because Turkey, Jordan, Egypt or Iraq would just love to see Iran with nuclear weapons.

      Don’t know much about the middle east, do you?

        1. And that’s exactly why they wouldn’t object to Israel’s attack on Iran’s nuke.

          shoot down Israeli jets on their way to Iran?
          they would throw rice and candy at them if it was possible.

          1. Delusion at its best. You’re in for a really nasty surprise when the dust finally settles…

          2. If they were smart they would realize that any Israeli jet that attacks Iran could just as easily turn around one day and attack them (and indeed would if Israel ever determined that they posed a threat of any sort).

          3. @Richard Silverstein
            they probably know that.

            but they DO want the Iranian nuclear program to be shut down, not less than Israel does, and they would prefer to let Israel do the dirty work, loose men and hardware, get the political flame and not do a damn thing, besides voting “yes” on the condemnation vote in the UN that will follow.
            Similar to the 1981 attack in Iraq and 2007 attack in Syria*.

            *In the attack on Syria, a nuclear facility could not have been attacked because the idea of Syria developing nuclear capabilities with the help of experts North Korea is totally preposterous.

    2. If the White House actually ordered the Joint Chiefs to stop Israel attacking Iran, they would destroy Israel’s (American supplied) strike forces on the ground rather than try and build a fifty billion dollar wall of SAM batteries around the Middle East. The Virginia Class boats could accomplish this with a minimum of help from B2s and B1Bs.

      The problem is, though, the extent to which Israel has “agents of influence” in American and Canadian society, and indeed the governments, to prevent any such order being even contemplated. The Director General of CSIS has acknowledged that agents of influence are a problem, the FBI acknowledges Israeli spying but not the agents of influence issue.

      Nazi Germany used to have a White List, of persons in the United Kingdom who they thought would cooperate with a Nazi puppet regime in the event of conquest or (more probably) coup. They also had a Black List, of persons to be rounded up and shot as swiftly as possible. Some of the names on the White List were wishful thinking, but they were probably right about two thirds of them. The Black List was “better safe than sorry” and rather longer in consequence.

      It’s pretty obvious that John Adelson and Cyril Reitman are not just on Israel’s White List: they are agents of influence who probably help compile the White List. The question then arises: does Israel have a Black List, of US and Canadian citizens who probably won’t cooperate with or even tolerate Israel’s attempted hijack of the North American political process?

      Given Mr Reitman’s past experience in “helping” both the FBI and the RCMP with their counter-subversion work, even if CSIS now believe that he invented and organized plots that he could help the FBI and RCMP uncover, he would be a prime candidate for author of any Israeli blacklist of North American citizens who might need to be compromised or eliminated in the event of any serious attempt by Israel to control American political decisions in a major crisis.

      Such a list might include a lot of names put there by spite rather than necessity; there are Gestapo documents from about 1944 suggesting that they thought that they thought the majority of people they had arrested in occupied Europe and Germany could have been left alone and had been fingered out of personal prejudice.

      Which is a long-winded way of saying that if there was a move in America towards actually stopping Israel, Prof. Silverstein would need to check his wheel arches before starting his car, and weigh his shaver a bit thoughtfully before shaving.

      What’s at stake here isn’t just peace in the Middle East, but American and Canadian Sovereignty. Tampering with this will either prove to be Israel’s masterstroke, or its means of suicide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *