I said my piece yesterday about Eli Lake’s fake expose on George Soros’ donations to J Street. But a new question came to me today. J Street is a 501c4. As such the IRS does not publicly disclose donors to such groups. So how did Lake get the names of Soros and the organization’s other major donors? My money is on a few possibilities: a Republican operative (perhaps in Congress), a former J Street staffer, or someone at the IRS. But however he got the data, my money is on Aipac, with its active intel capabilities, or the Republican Jewish Coalition (or someone perhaps freelancing who is closely associated with it) as playing a major role in facilitating this.
Think of the timing: there is only a month remaining before the mid-term elections. Control of the House and possibly the Senate lies in the balance. Even a few elections in states with large Jewish populations in which J Street could play a major role (think Joe Sestak)–even this could swing the balance from blue to red. If J Street is wounded. If its donations dry up at this vital juncture, then those few candidates will have less money to place ads on TV. Their message will be stifled. And even if there is only a marginal impact on the campaigns through this fake scandal, then big things could result for Republicans.
I’d guess my money would be on the RJC for that very reason. They have everything to gain from these revelations. Their past sleazy behavior has proven that they have little to lose in the scruples or morals department. So there’s almost no downside for them even if eventually someone (not Eli Lake) discovers that they were involved. The RJC is built on sleaze. It thrives on it. In fact, I bet, if they were involved, that Matt Brooks is high-fiving it up as I write this.
Yes, it’s true, this is speculation. No smoking gun, yet. But who knows. The circle turns. The joker is sometimes unmasked.
The media is rife with stories about how dirty political media campaigns have become in this election cycle, about how opaque the funding is. But Lake’s story has proven that there can be a flip side. If you have a highly motivated, well-funded, and skilled enemy, they can hurt you. Once again, this proves the stupidity of the Supreme Court’s decision to turn U.S. federal elections into the Wild, Wild West. It shows the virtue of full transparency in the sphere of campaign funding. I say force J Street and every other 501c4 including ones financed by the fatcats of Aipac and RJC to publicly name their donors and how much they gave.
And I warn whichever Republican spook secured Lake’s scoop for him: what goes around comes around. And I hope to God that you, and whatever 501c4 you’re affiliated with, are next.
NOTE: I just read Ron Kampeas’ fabulous blog post on this story. Among his best lines is:
J Street has a “who am I” problem.
Which is precisely what I write above and have been writing here for a year or more. Are they for Iran sanctions or agin ’em (for ’em now, agin ’em before they were for ’em)? Are they for Goldstone or agin ‘im (a little of both)? Are they independent and progressive or Obama’s “blocking back?”
Kampeas really nails Lake far better than even I can do, because he swims in the same pool as they do as a Jewish journalist and because Kampeas has far more experience covering this inside the Beltway political zone. I apologize for including Ron in my challenge of yesterday as to journalists who should digging at this and related stories harder. But I’d still like to see Ron and other work at unearthing the sugar daddies of the right wing pro Israel 501c4s.
Richard,
Here in New York State, a non-profit organization has to disclose the finacials to the public. Only if you are a religious
organization are you exempt.
I am pretty sure this is true nation-wide.
Peace.
Michael Santomauro
Awake in New York City
J Street is tax exempt but donations are not tax deductible, therefore neither the IRS nor the group has to disclose them. I don’t know how this is reflected in state law.
You are nicer to Ron Kampeas than he deserves. In fast-food restaurant terms, the JTA is a Jack-in-the-Box with a history of salmonella, and Ron Kampeas is the head chef.
Actually, I’ve got some history with various reporters & editors at JTA and Ron’s the best of ’em all. Ami Eden and Ben Harris are useless, but Ron gets things right far more often than any of the rest of them. Plus, he’s been a straight shooter with me and given me credit for breaking several stories he’s covered. That’s more than I can say for some of the major world media which have often ignored my contribution to stories.
It is unclear whether the source of the Soros donation is nefarious or legal/open.
To be precise, J Street is both a PAC and a c4. The c4 arm, like a 501c3, is required to make its form 990 (tax return for federal nonprofits) public. I downloaded the 2008 and 2009 returns last night from http://www.guidestar.org. Neither one discloses donors by name — only the total amount given. There is more than enough total donation listed (about $1.6 million in 2009) to make the reported Soros donation possible.
Specific donors are not listed on the 990. But PACs do have to file their donation lists with the Federal Election Commission. I searched for Soros in the FEC database and did not find a matching donation large enough.
States have disclosure laws for PACs that in many cases are more complete than the federal, though.