I was duped by the Mossad. I’m not proud of it. It hurts as a journalist to be taken. You never want to be fooled by a source. But I was. This is how it happened.
In 2010, I published a story based on a leak from Mossad official, Rami Igra (it came from him via former defense minister and IDF general, Benjamin Ben Eliezer), saying that Iranian general, Ali Reza Asgari, had defected to the west and, after interrogation, died in an Israeli prison.
A few years later, I learned that the story was largely false and fed deliberately by the Mossad to conceal two major Mossad intelligence failures. In fact, the Iranian general had not defected, but had been kidnapped in 2006 by Israeli agents in Turkey.
Captured Israeli airman, Ron Arad
It did so in the false belief he could reveal the whereabouts of a downed IAF pilot, Ron Arad, captured in Lebanon in 1988. The general had no such information. Iran had not been involved in the capture and knew nothing about it. When Mossad discovered this, it murdered him. Then dumped his body in the Black Sea.
This recalls a spectacular, though little-known disastrous Shin Bet mission. In 1954, it uncovered a security breach by an IDF officer who offered to sell military secrets to the Egyptians. He was kidnapped in Paris through a honeypot sting. A medical doctor, part of the kidnapping team, injected him to render him unconscious. He died during the return flight to Israel either from an overdose or massive seizure (depending on the source). The Shin Bet chief at the time ordered the kidnappers to dump his body in the Mediterranean. In those days, one could hush up such a disaster and the story was suppressed by the agency and military censor for five decades.
The NY Times broke the Arad-Asgari story yesterday. Noted Israeli security journalist, Yossi Melman, expanded upon it in a tweet:
The New York Times’ expose of the Mossad’s abduction of Iranian General Alireza Asgari in Turkey in 2007, in an attempt to obtain information about missing Israeli airman Ron Arad, and his subsequent killing by Mossad operatives, is astonishing.
Mossad murdered Iranian general, Alireza Asgari
According to the NYT, Asgari was killed after being interrogated and after it became clear that he had no information about Arad. Hints that he had been murdered by the Mossad had appeared previously in Iranian and Arab media. The American anti-Israel blogger Richard Silverstein had also written about the possibility. However, he claimed that Asgari had been murdered in Ramla Prison, where he was held in the so-called X-wing, a high-security isolation unit.
At the time, the X-wing housed Ben Zygier, an Australian-born Jewish Mossad operative who had been arrested after boasting about operations in Iran, information about which apparently reached an Iranian source. Zygier subsequently could not bear the accusations and the pressure by his interrogators and committed suicide in prison. Unaware of this, Silverstein received a tip suggesting that the man who had died in the X-wing was Asgari and that he had been murdered.
Asgari, a general in Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), had operated, among other places, in Lebanon and maintained close ties with Hezbollah. He had also served as deputy defense minister. By the time of his murder, however, he was a former official who had fallen out of favor with the government of the hardlin…President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.
There is considerable irony in the fact that, years later, Mossad chief David Barnea and senior members of the agency approached Ahmadinejad and cultivated him as a potential future leader of Iran, in the event that the futile regime-change operation conceived by Netanyahu and Trump had succeeded during the February 2026 war.
I suspect that the Mossad tried to persuade Asgari to defect, offering him extraordinary inducements and promises. But he apparently refused to betray his country. That refusal may have sealed his fate, leading to the decision to eliminate him.
The Mossad was then headed by Meir Dagan. A decision of this magnitude would have required the prime minister’s approval. In 2007, that position was held by Ehud Olmert.
At the same time, the Mossad’s psychological warfare unit disseminated disinformation intended to mislead, confuse and cover up the killing. According to this version of events, Asgari had defected voluntarily, shared everything he knew about Iran, was interrogated by Israeli and American intelligence officials, and was subsequently resettled in Germany under a new identity.
…No less important, and perhaps even more serious, is the need to examine the Mossad’s entrenched intelligence assumptions – its own preconceived notions (the konseptzia in Hebrew).
For many years, both the Shin Bet and senior Mossad officials believed that Iran had no involvement in Ron Arad’s fate…Their conclusion was that Arad had most likely been murdered by someone close to Hezbollah in the village of Nabi Sheet, in south Lebanon where he was being held. The killing was believed to have been an act of revenge for the death of one of the perpetrator’s relatives in an Israeli airstrike in 1988.
Now Iran has another reason to seek revenge against Israel: You killed one of our generals.
In short, intelligence rigidity and the desire to demonstrate success at any cost- even when the circumstances point to deeply questionable assumptions – are a recipe for disaster.
Elements in Israeli intelligence falsely believed that after Arad’s plane crashed and he was captured, the Iranians took him. By some accounts, he was moved from the Lebanese village where he was being held, to Iran. That led the Israelis to mistakenly believe that Iranian intelligence officials knew where he was, if alive, or where he was buried, if dead. This conviction was wrong and led to a series of disastrous covert operations, which ended in abject failure. To this day, the Mossad believes Arad is dead and is likely buried in or around the original village where he was held as a prisoner.
One of the great ironies of the Ron Arad saga is that contrary to the once-sacred obligation never to leave a man behind and exert every effort to bring soldiers home, either alive or dead–the IDF now maintains a policy of actually killing its own captured soldiers. It’s called the Hannibal Directive, which I’ve documentedhere for the pastdecade. In other words, it’s better to kill your own than have to negotiate a prisoner exchange which will free Palestinian prisoners. It is but one of hundreds of bizarre, cruel, anti-human approaches Israel has adopted. They are the epitome of modern Zionism. Hannibal was most recently invoked on 10/7, when IDF helicopter pilots knowingly fired on vehicles transporting captured Israelis into Gaza. In subsequent TV interviews, they conceded that they were acting in accordance to the Directive.
Returning to the campaign to find Arad, the Times suggests “…that Israeli intelligence officials had [not] intentionally misled the government over the decades about Iran’s role.“ However, that does not hold true regarding the subsequent cover-up of the disastrous assumptions leading to this failure.
The false information Igra fed to me served several purposes: it concealed the Mossad’s failure to find Arad and its false assumptions on which it was based; It led the Iranians to believe Asgari was in Israeli custody and may be revealing Iranian intelligence secrets it permitted the Mossad to conceal a second major failure.
A disgraced Mossad agent: a second intelligence failure
Ex-Mossad agent, Ben Zygier’s grave
In 2010, a young Mossad agent, Ben Zygier, had inadvertently exposed intelligence secrets to a Hezbollah spy. The Israeli was secretly arrested and imprisoned. Military censorship prohibited any reporting on the story. In 2013, an Australian media outlet finally broke the story thanks to a leak from the national intelligence agency.
In truth, the prisoner in the Israeli prison was not the Iranian general, but Zygier. The former had died, in fact been murdered. The Israeli had also died, but by suicide in an Israeli prison. Zygier, despondent over his wife abandoning him and his indefinite imprisonment, had committed suicide, thanks in part due to the incompetent surveillance of prison guards. Thus, the Mossad had a new fiasco: it had permitted one of its agents–who had betrayed secrets, lost hope, become suicidal—to die by his own hand and under its own watch. It desperately wanted to cover up the scandal and ensure the truth would be suppressed.
Melman confirmed a concerted campaign of disinformation regarding the Asgari case:
The Mossad’s psychological warfare unit disseminated disinformation intended to mislead, confuse and cover up the killing. According to this version of events, Asgari had defected voluntarily, shared everything he knew about Iran, was interrogated by Israeli and American intelligence officials, and was subsequently resettled in Germany under a new identity.–
This level of disinformation appears to be similar to the confusion provoked by Ben Zygier’s death. The misdirection of the leak to me appears to be part of a similar campaign. In a separate article published a month after Zygier died, Melman offered a fuller assessment. He undoubtedly knew about the Asgari-Zygier “switch” and the disinformation fed to me, but couldn’t report it fully due to Israeli military censorship:
On December 11, blogger, Richard Silverstein, speculated that the prisoner in question must have been Asgari, prompting the Iranian missive to the Secretary General of the UN. Under a gag order, the Israeli media cannot investigate the matter any further.
However the chances that the mysterious Israeli prisoner was Asgari are very slim. The prisoner was more likely to have been a former officer of the Israeli intelligence services convicted of treason.
Coincidentally, Igra leaked his story to me on December 10, 2010 and I published it the following day. According to media reports, Zygier committed suicide four days later on December 15th. It’s possible that he in fact died before December 10th, which spurred the Mossad to devise its cover story.
Mossad’s long record of intelligence failures
These two disastrous adventures were by no means the only ones committed by the agency over the course of its existence, despite its vaunted reputation for daring and invulnerability. They happened repeatedly beginning in 1948 and extending to the present day.
Most recently, Israel misjudged its ability to destroy Iran’s leadership and overthrow the clerical regime. It devised a slapdash plan involving a march by Kurdish militias from northern Iran to Tehran, where it would overthrow the government; air assaults which would eliminate the political and military leadership; and the installation of its former enemy, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad as its new puppet ruler.
While it did kill much of the leadership, those officials were rapidly replaced by subordinates and other figures who were far more radical than their predecessors. The Kurds failed to rise up and march to the capital. And Ahmedinejad thought better of the Israeli scheme and refused to cooperate. Finally, though the US and Israel both bombed Iranian nuclear facilities, subsequent intelligence analysis discovered that while they were damaged, they were not eliminated as expected.
These assumptions were based on exaggerated, even delusional assumptions about the Mossad’s capacity to shape events, destroy its enemies, and impose its dominance in regional affairs. Unless US presidents refuse to be drawn into such future misadventures as Trump was, and impose a veto on them—including arms embargo—such disasters will continue; with the danger that they could do precisely what the Iran war has done—damaged the world economy due to a shipping blockade, drawn US regional allies unwillingly into the conflict, and dragged the US into an endless conflict which has damaged our military deterrence in the face of major rivals such as China. Thus an ambitious, foolhardy US ally has drawn it into a disastrous war it never should have fought in the first place. Unless it changes this policy, it will not be the last such disaster.
Like this:
LikeLoading…
Related
Discover more from Tikun Olam תיקון עולם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.