
Global media are reporting that the election results were “inconclusive,, “deadlocked,” or “no clear winner.” That’s only if you presume that Israelis governments exclude the Palestinian vote and parties. Which of course is racist. Though of course this has been the Jewish parties’ practice, with one brief exception, since the founding of the (so-called) Jewish democratic state.
If you do include the Palestinian parties in yesterday’s result, it was a resounding success for the broad, inclusive Opposition; and a resounding defeat for Netanyahu. His Likud collapsed, falling precipitously from 32 in the current Knesset to 26 in the next. His coalition of far-right and Orthodox parties has 53 seats. There are no other conceivable combinations that would get him to the 61 necessary to form a government. Unless he peels away one of the Opposition parties like Avigdor Lieberman. Though he hates Netanyahu, so this seems unlikely.
It is an extraordinary showing for the Israeli-Palestinian parties, who have never cracked 15 seats in previous elections. Turnout among their commuity was 80%. A normal election turnout hits about 65%. What brought them out? Three words: Itamar Ben Gvir. They see him. They see what he is. No matter how hard their lives might be under a less toxic government, this was intolerable. The genocide of their cousins in Gaza and the West Bank. The rapes in Israeli prisons. The settler pogroms on the West Bank. They had enough and they wanted to send a message.
But will Jewish Israel get the message? Will Gadi Eisenkot get the message? Will Avigdor Lieberman? Or will they remain mired in Zionist-supremacism?
What does this defeat portend for Netanyahu? After five terms and endless protests against his cynical policies, he may be at the end of the road. Though of course he is the political vampire who continually rises from the dead. So he can’t be fully counted out. Nevertheless, any other leader facing such a defeat would be removed from Party leadership. Netanyahu is no normal leader. But neither is he immortal. This may be the final curtain.
Eisenkot’s Jewish coalition partners finished with a disappointing 48 seats. Considering the hatred which many Israelis feel toward the prime minister, it’s astonishing his parties did so poorly. This result has thrown him on the mercy of the Israeli-Palestinians. A place he does not want to be.
Eisenkot failed to generate excitement because he is a terrible, marble-mouthed speaker. His message, such as it was, offered little more than the amorphous “change.” Israelis are generally very cynical about election politics. While they flock to candidates who really seem to offer change, or a new approach, they remain unmoved by the traditional Jewish parties. They’ve been burned repeatedly in the past in terms of their expectations. The Opposition leader failed to resonate because he played it safe. “Safe” in Israeli politics means the status quo, which is disastrous.
Israel faces increasing ostracism globally (thanks to Netanyahu). The first meaningful set of sanctions have been imposed by 12 European nations. Without real change in national security policy, they will become more severe. It is an inexorable process unless it changes course. Additionally, in 2028, there is a strong possibility (or likelihood) of a Democratic president. Given the radical changes in the Democratic Party and attitudes toward Israel, relations with Israel could enter a downhill slide.
No doubt, the domestic Israel Lobby remains a formidable force. But as we’re seeing in the midterm elections, hundreds of millions in campaign cash doesn’t win many elections, as it used to. When you start out with an electoral base which has turned against you, it’s difficult to compensate for that with money and attack ads alone. Further, attempts to conceal its influence through stealth PACs with innocuous names which hide Aipac’s hidden hand, don’t have much success.
If a new more centrist government retains the same basic outlines as the current far-right one, along with a lukewarm Democratic administration, Israel drifts farther out to sea.
The number of countries prepared to impose sanctions will rise. They will become more severe, more draconian. They will begin to harm Israel industry including its arms exports. They will also damage the technology companies which provide an enormous share of the country’s export market. This, in turn will hurt the average Israeli consumer, who currently faces no impact from the country’s disastrous security policy in Gaza, Lebanon, Syria and Iran.
If he faces the music and brings the Israeli-Palestinians into his government, party leaders like Lieberman may bolt. He is a right-wing Judeo-supremacist. But more pragmatic than the other right-wing racists in Netanyahu’s coalition. Will he go or will he stay if Eisenkot adds the Palestinians? That is the perpetual unsettling drama of Israeli coalition-building.
The worst-case scenario is neither side forms a coalition and the country goes to a second set of elections. It has happened once before and led to an unstable center-right coalition which lasted barely a year. A second set of elections will change little and likely be almost as inconclusive. It may give one bloc an advantage. But the country will remain divided.
In the event that Eisenkot does form a coalition, the key question will be how much, if anything, will the country’s military strategy change? The key indicators will be:
- Iran
- Gaza
- West Bank
- Lebanon and Syria
If he climbs down from the current hawkish approach to Iran, it will be a welcome and radical shift. If he ends the continuing genocide in Gaza and withdraws some or all his troops occupying 70% of the territory, that too would be a serious change. If he clamps down on the settler ethnic-cleansing campaign in the West Bank and arrests the Judeo terrorists, it would unprecedented. If he ends the occupations of Lebanon and Syria, it would be an enormous shift from the current assault.
Will he make any of these changes? I would guess he will make some, but not all of them. Will these changes mark a substantive change from his predecessor? Pessimism is warranted. No Israeli government since 1977 has ever shown a willingness to compromise: to recognize a Palestinian state, to offer its Palestinian citizens full and equal rights, to embrace diplomacy over military force, to seek genuine peace with its neighbors. This government will likely not break much new ground on these issues. But even if it approaches these issues differently than its predecessor. it will be better than what Israel has now. How much better is an open question.
Discover more from Tikun Olam תיקון עולם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Richard, if Netanyahu is able to force a second election, do you think the Palestinians would turn out to vote in the same numbers. Would many not be (further) disillusioned? Also, would Netanyahu and his allies not contrive to suppress Palestinian voting through increasing 8ntimidation?
Eisenkot doesn’t actually need to include the Arab parties into the Government in order for him to become Prime Minister.
Israel has a Westminster-style democracy, which means that the Parliament is where the Executive branch (ie the “Government”) is drawn from, and that government rises or falls depending upon what happens on the floor of that Parliament.
So Eisenkot doesn’t have to offer the Arab parties any ministerial positions in his government. He doesn’t have to offer them ANY official position inside his government. All he needs is a public undertaking from the Arab parties that they will vote for him in any “no-confidence vote” in the Knesset, and will vote again Netanyahu in any equivalent “no-confidence vote”.
In a Westminster-style democracy that settles the issue: the President has to appoint Eisenkot as Prime Minister, and the dude will remain Prime Minister for as long as he wins any “no-confidence vote” on the floor of the Knesset.
Eisenkot would, in effect, be running a “minority government” ie he will be governing the country with “the support of” but not with “the participation of” the Arab parties.
Heck, Eisenkot can make a deal with the Arab List that would make Machiavelli blush: support me in the Knesset UNTIL Netanyahu stands trial and is sent to prison and then he will go to Herzog and ask his to dissolve the Knesset and call new elections.
Nothing but his own lack of boldness prevents him from stitching up such a deal, and (presumably, though you never know) such a deal won’t offend Lieberman because (a) it ends Netanyahu (yah!) and (b) it does not involve the Arab parties actually being part of Eisenkot’s minority government.
@ Yeah, Right: The presumption of cynical racist Zionists that a Palestinian (not “Arab”) coalition, 3rd largest in the Knesset, would settle for remaining 2nd class citizens–and be excluded from the table where real power lies–is racist and offensive. I believe that this time, after suffering through the same arrangement in the past, they will refuse your “kind offer.” Even another Judeo-Nazi government, as bad as it might be, would continue & increase global disgust and an ever-increasing sanctions regime. In the long run, that’s better than being a political also-ran.
Politics is by its very nature about getting what you can achieve, which is not necessarily the same thing as what you want to achieve.
This is very simple: if Eisenkot offers the Arab politicians positions within his proposed government then Lieberman WILL bolt from the opposition and strike a deal with Netanyahu, at which point Netanyahu will continue to govern Israel.
That outcome is inevitable IF Eisenkot offers the Arab parties a role in his government, and so arguing for that is totally and utterly self-defeating.
So don’t do that, because doing that doesn’t help anyone but Netanyahu.
Do something different, and as far as I can tell Eisenkot has only one path forward if he wants to see Netanyahu end up in jail.
And, once more, yet again, it is this: inform Herzog that he can form a minority government because the Arab parties have agreed to support him in the Knesset.
That’s it. That is the ONLY way that Eisenkot can form a government because that is the ONLY way he can keep Lieberman in his coalition.
Because – again, this needs to be stressed – if Lieberman bolts then Netanyahu is the next Prime Minister.
@ Yeah: No, politics is far more nuanced than that. Politics is also about social change–about adopting new attitudes and laws that reflect those changes. Like equal rights, political and human. Like a state for all its citizens. Those will come or else Israel will eventually collapse.
Lieberman hates Netanyahu. He would never enter a Likud government as he has refused to do in the past.
Whenever a Zionist says “it is very simple” you know it isn’t simple at all. Or if it is simple, it’s the exact opposite of what he claims.
The trial has gone on for 4 yrs. IF you think a new government will complete the trial and convict him you are beyond naive. There is no such thing as Israeli justice. It is a sham. The powerful are never punished. That includes prime ministers or ex-prime ministers. Olmert was the exception.
No it isn’t. There are 3 Haredi parties. If all or most of them join, then he forms a government. A bad, weak one. But still a government.
Not at all. Bibi cannot peel off any of the Opposition coalition. There would be new elections.
That’s only if you believe the sole purpose of the election was to rid the nation of Bibi. That’s only one of the goals. Another is to guarantee equality and rights to Israeli Palestinians. The nation isn’t worth anyathing as long as it denies them. And this is not for another time. It is for now.
You can live denying justice to Palestinian citizens. But they can’t and democracy can’t. It is far more inmportant than dirty backroom deals like those Eisenkot plans. Not to mention, that deals with the Haredim as he contemplates create a weak coalition cobbled together without any policy coherence.
Do not use the term “Arab” here. It is racist. It is Palestine denial. And do not publish another comment in this thread. You are only permitted one comment per thread.
[your comment has been deleted–you are permitted ONE comment per thread as I noted]
If you think it’s just thanks to Netanyahu, you aren’t paying attention.
Poll after poll shows the overwhelming majority support ethnic cleansing.
The entire society is sick and twisted to its core.
@ Simon O: You should read more of the blog. You’ll see that your impression of my views is not accurate. I am paying attention and have for the past 23 yrs writing this blog.
The complete irony is Eisenkot is an arab, Gvir is a Kurd – seems the arabs and their mates hate Palestinians even more than Bibi and the Euro trash
@ Marilyn: On the whole, there is truth in that. But there are many mizrahim who are anti-Zionist. My friend Smadar Lavie is one among many. Nor forget the historic Israeli Black Panthers.
What is there to choose?
“Change bloc” leaders Yair Lapid, Naftali Bennett, Avigdor Liberman, Yair Golan and Gadi Eisenkot
See ICJ decisions and ICC arrest warrants.
link to cfr.org