Haaretz's misleading headline implying Ellison and Farrakhan enjoyed a tete a tete in 2013
Apparently, some Jewish racists have been hunting through the photo archives to find pictures of Louis Farrakhan or other known anti-Semites, which also include other prominent African-American leaders. They then trot the photos out to right-wing media outlets like the Wall Street Journal, Algemeiner, Free Beacon or even Breitbart (which has become an honorary pro-Israel shmatteh), which splash them across the front page. Reporters then dutifully call national Jewish leaders and ask them to express their outrage at the temerity of Barack Obama or Keith Ellison having lunch or dinner or cocktails privately with Louis Farrakhan. Anything to smear the reputations of African-American leaders and force them to toe a pro-Israel line.
It’s unseemly, it’s hypocritical, it’s pure unadulterated chutzpah. Barack Obama owes neither Greenblatt nor anyone an explanation for why he attended a Congressional Black Caucus luncheon in 2005 (three years before he ran for president) at which Louis Farrakhan was an invited guest. Similarly, Ellison owes no one an apology for attending a dinner hosted by Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani in New York City, along with hundreds of other Iranian-Americans, Muslims, and many others–just because one of those hundreds of individuals was Louis Farrakhan.
1/5 Still gathering information about this mtg. Based on what we know, its extremely disturbing that Dem reps or members of any political group would attend a session hosted by hatemongers. https://t.co/LIlMXNyQev
— Jonathan Greenblatt (@JGreenblattADL) February 12, 2018
Haaretz described the event as a “private dinner” with Farrakhan and Ellison. It was only private in the sense that people were invited to attend, thousands of people were invited. So in that sense it was quite a public dinner. I know people who were invited and believe me I’m not the best connected person in the world when it comes to such things.
The Wall Street Journal wrote this misleadingly alarming description: “In September 2013…Messrs. Ellison and Farrakhan dined together.” Yeah, they dined together with a few hundred of their closest, most intimate friends. People, this is much ado about nothing.
To blame Ellison or claim he’s insensitive to anti-Semitism because a single guest held views offensive to Jews is beyond ridiculous. I, for example have attended scores of similar major fundraising dinners when I was a fundraiser for several Jewish community federations, a hospital, and university. Did I vet all guests to determine whether they’d ever made racist, misogynist or anti-Semitic remarks, or even whether they’d committed criminal acts? Of course not. Is it possible there were such individuals at such dinners? Sure. What does Greenblatt expect? That prominent guests at such events must demand the guest list from the hosts to determine whether they’re rubbing shoulders with unsavory characters? Or should such guests demand veto power over who attends the events lest someone embarrass them?
In Israel catching up on news about 2005 photo of Obama & Farrakhan. Over his career, @barackobama has denounced the bigotry of Farrakhan. Time to do so again. Leaders always should make sure that there’s no doubt: America is no place for those who advocate #antisemitism or hate
— Jonathan Greenblatt (@JGreenblattADL) January 29, 2018
Greenblatt had the chutzpah to tweet that Obama owed him (or us) an apology (his actual words were “it’s time [for Obama] to denounce bigotry again,”) but he was essentially demanding an Ashamnu from the former president for his “gaffe” in showing his face at an event featuring Farrakhan. Get over it, Greenblatt. He’s a former president of the United States. He doesn’t owe you anything. He doesn’t owe me anything. He doesn’t owe American Jews anything on this score.
I strongly advise the Jewish leaders having hissy fits over this to calm down, take a deep breath, go study a blatt of gemara, and find other ways to spend their time. This doesn’t do the Jewish community any good. It’s Jewsplaining of the worst sort. If Jews want to stay alert for real, dangerous, toxic anti-Semitism take a look at the White House or Breitbart or Orange County, where a nice Jewish college boy was murdered by a neo-Nazi thug (not a word from Greenblatt about that heinous murder). Because telling Black leaders who they can and can’t consort with is obnoxious. Cut it out, now.
Not only the WSJ, but also an article in The Forward …
Keith Ellison Attended Private Dinner With Iran’s President And Louis Farrakhan
Please don’t forget the link with Iran and its intent for the “destruction” of Israel.
Thanks Oui.
Embedded in the link you provided is a recent Farrakhan video interview that shows that he is an unrepentant Jew-hater. We all need to be reminded of Farrakhan’s deep hatred of Jews, Whites and Gays.
https://www.facebook.com/OfficialMinisterFarrakhan/videos/1179160955524508/
@Dr. John: Erm, no we don’t. Most of us who are sentient know this quite well & don’t need to be reminded. But there you’ve gone & told us something we already know…
Is this Farrakhan that important, that we all need to be reminded of this particular person’s views?
The ADL was one of the leading groups that smeared Congressman Keith Ellison to prevent him from becoming the DNC Chairperson, by saying that Ellison attended the Million Man March in Washington led by Farrakhan in 1995. So did a lot of other respectable people who asked people to come to express their views, while not necessarily endorsing Farrakhan’s. I’m not absolutely sure, but I think that the ADL charged that Ellison was an anti-semite. A man in my city who is a Democratic Party hack, actually made that claim to me. Jewish people by overwhelming numbers always vote for Ellison who is an honorable person, every time he comes up for election in his Minnesota district.
Let’s flip this on its end.
Through circumstances I won’t get into, I’d become acquainted with a nearby Evangelical church.
And they’d done several nice things for me. So I decided to attend services. It makes them happy. Doesn’t do anything for me, but it’s not all about me. Not all the time, anyway.
So off I go. Sigh. There’s an Israeli flag against the wall. Then somebody gets up and blows the shofar. Then a sweet old white lady gets up and makes a tearful plea for Israel.
And there I was. Am I therefore an Israel supporter? Ahem: read my posts.
@ Colin
“.. a sweet old white lady gets up and makes a tearful plea for Israel.”
Maybe you will find inspiration with another ministry.
One wonders what you mean. Perhaps you should explain.
[Comment deleted: what is it you didn’t understand about my denunciation of Jewsplaining?]
Mr. Silverstein. can you please investigate the story about syrian missiles flying over tel aviv. as usual the censor killed it. the truth is only thing that will let me sleep. that syrian rockets are leaving trails almost over my roof is not a good idf propaganda
please, thank
The logic of this Obama-Farrakhan thing is ridiculous. With this logic the fact that vice president Pence sat close to North Korean officials at an Olympics event last weekend proves that he is a dupe of North Korea.
Following the ridiculous Obama-Farrakhan logic, Vice President Pence is a dupe of North Korea: after all he sat very close to North Korean officials at a Winter Olympics event last weekend.
Following the ridiculous Obama-Farrakhan logic, Vice President Pence is a dupe of North Korea: he sat very close to several North Korean leaders durng the Winter Olympics opening ceremony last weekend. He should be shipped directly to Pyongyang so he can be with his pals, or maybe better to Guantanamo.
‘…He should be shipped directly to Pyongyang so he can be with his pals, or maybe better to Guantanamo.’
To be fair, that idea does have its points.