Mahzor

New York Public Library

Churches

Sarajevo Haggadah

Mah Nishtanah

Sarajevo haggadah

Antaea Darom

Israeli women's art

Action

Torah as music

Ben Heine

Action

ceramic bowl

Mohammad Said Kalash, "Offering Reconciliation" exhibit (photo: Ilan Amihai)

Action

Punch and Judy/Pinchas and Jamila

Avi Katz

Action

David Grossman

Ben Heine

Action

Eldrige Street shul

Lower East Side

Action

Dove

Ben Heine

Action

Two birds

Hoda Jamal

Action

Israeli and Palestinian boys

from documentary, Promises

Action

Cat in the Hat

Yiddish version

Action

Daylight through the Wall

Banksy: graffiti art on Separation Wall

Action

Maurice Sendak's Brundibar set

New Victory Theater (photo: Nan Melville/NYT)

Action

Daniel Barenboim, West-Eastern Divan Orchestra

Palestinian-Israeli musical ensemble (photo: Kerstin Joensson/AP)

Action

Great Day on Eldrige Street

N.Y.'s klezmer greats celebrate shul rededication (photo: Leo Sorel)

Action

Joint Appeal for Peace

(Avi Katz)

Joint Appeal for Peace

Ketubah, Ancona, Italy (1772)

(Jewish Theological Seminary library)

Ancona ketubah

Posts Tagged ‘mustafa dirani’

Captain George (aka Doron Zahavi) Rides Again

Sunday, December 18th, 2011

One thing you have to say about Israeli torturers, you can’t keep a good one down. I reported here some time ago about one Doron Zahavi aka Captain George, an infamous commander of the IDF intelligence unit 504. Until my report, his real name was secret and no publication has reported it. I was delighted to bring his brutal acts into the public light and attach a real name to the torturer. Zahavi and his boys specialized in “interrogating” (i.e. torturing) foreign security suspects captured by the IDF abroad.

One of them was Mustafa Dirani, who Israel suspected of having held the MIA airman, Ron Arad. Zahavi subjected Dirani to the “royal treatment” which included sodomizing him with a billy club. We know this because Dirani sued the State and is attempting to hold it accountable for what its represenative did to him. One of the reasons Dirani exposed methods of torture used by Unit 504 is that the Supreme Court forced the State to allow him to proceed with his claims against it. In the process, Zahavi’s commander, a colonel whose first initial is Het, had a bout of conscience and spilled the beans. Here are some of the Zahavi’s patented methods (in Hebrew):

Het said Captain George played a role in every interrogation. “He would just come in, burst into the room, grab the suspect, shake him, get him onto the floor, punch him in the chest, yell and threaten,” Het said. Het added that George would enter with a baton, hit the suspect and threaten to insert it into his rectum if he “continued to lie or not talk.” Het also recounted an interrogation in which George allegedly stripped a suspect naked and forced him to drink tea or coffee from an ashtray full of cigarette ashes and then forced shaving cream or toothpaste into the suspect’s mouth. “I simply walked out,” Het said. Het said George dealt with almost every case involving an infiltrator into Israel from a neighboring country, including Iran, Iraq and Syria, but also in special circumstances such as the interrogation of Dirani. Het recalled an instance in which he inserted a baton into a suspect’s rectum and asked him [Het] to sit on the baton unless the suspect was willing to speak.

The Hebrew version is even more graphic. It describes further brutality by Zahavi:

He always employed brutality. I was shocked. I would sit in the room and watch [shocked]. He would come into the interrogation room, knock the detainee off the bench, jump on him, kick him, threaten that he would fuck him, or that others would fuck him and rape him. The detainees were afraid of him.

Het said that the reason Zahavi was never charged with any violation was that his superiors didn’t want to deal with investigations or committees of inquiry:

When you have dirty laundry you don’t want to wash it outside because everyone [in the unit] could be hurt by it. That’s why everyone tried to close it internally, within the family and not to take it outside.

Het continued that though everyone knew that Zahavi had gone “bad,” no one wanted to deal with it because he got results:

It didn’t matter that those results might do a grave injustice to some of the detainees because results were obtained under threat or torture. Maybe the suspect was even completely clean and had no connection whatever to the incident being investigated.

Note that Het exposes precisely the problem with CIA waterboarding and other forms of torture: you extract information from the victim, but is it good information or stuff he made up to stop the suffering? The reason this story has come back into the news is that the State has now warned Het that he may be subject to criminal prosecution for his previous testimony. On the face of it, they may be charging him with some of the crimes he admitted to participating in under Zahavi’s command. Of course, though the IDF fired Zahavi after this nastiness was exposed, it never prosecuted him.

This allowed him to rise to his level of brutality in another capacity: the Israeli police hired him to be the “liaison” with the East Jerusalem Palestinian population. Don’t you dare think of community policing when you think of what this guy does. He yells and screams at Silwan community activists and threatens them unless they offer intelligence or become spies. This is how the Zahavis of the world operate. So in this best of all possible world for torturers called Israel, Doron Zahavi lands on his feet in a cushy new job while Het, the soldier with a conscience, may end up in jail. The reason? You don’t wash the IDF’s laundry in public. If you do, they’ll come after you too. “Vengeance is mine,” saith the IDF.

Though the army closed Unit 504 after Dirani’s expose caused great embarrassment, a few months ago it brought the unit back apparently by popular demand. Now that the CIA has cut down on water boarding and other forms of torture I guess there’s high demand for the services of animals like Zahavi.

Zahavi is suing the IDF for wrongful termination. He claims that his superior officers knew everything he did and approved it. He’s likely correct and figures that they’ll settle with him rather than drag guys who may even now be cabinet ministers of members of the senior IDF command into court. Those officers may even be pressuring the State not to fight Zahavi and to prosecute Het, the source of their woes to their mind.

IDF: Wages of Terror Are Sodomy

Thursday, June 23rd, 2011

The wages of sin may be death in the New Testament.  But in the IDF the wages of terror appear to be sodomy.

I don’t know why it is that the IDF finds it especially appropriate to mete our the punishments of sodomy for suspected terrorists in its hands.  We know, for example, that IDF military torturer Doron Zahavi (aka Captain George) supervised the sodomy and torture of Lebanese prisoner Mustafa Dirani because it was suspected that he was an Amal terrorist who knew something about the kidnapping of Ron Arad.

Similarly, an Israeli rapist admitted his crime in this post from Yulie Cohen’s Blog Ishi (Hebrew) in which he described his rape of a fellow soldier at age 19, while they served in the IDF.  He was attempting to exorcise his demons and expiate his sin, and also to make a statement about how common such acts and the thought processes that lead to them are among Israeli men.

Now, Erez Efrati, a former bodyguard for IDF chief of staff Gaby Ashkenazi is falling on the mercy of an Israeli court in the appeal of his conviction for raping and attempted sodomy of a woman after a stag party.  He got eight years for the crime.  And the grounds of his appeal?  He mistook her for a terrorist.  Keep in mind that he’s outside a Tel Aviv club when this happens, not guarding the Gaza border.  Anyway, he sees this dark shadowy figure and his military training immediately kicks in and he…rapes her.  Does this tell us something about how the IDF trains its finest young men, the ones selected for coveted assignments like guarding the chief of staff?  Or does it tell us the guy is full of s(^t?

At yesterday’s hearing, Efrati claimed he had thought the complainant was a terrorist and acted in accordance with his professional training.

“I passed a shadowy figure and I felt my pulse in my throat as the figure moved to my side,” he said. “The figure entered the car and I flew at this figure, pulling the keys out of the ignition as in my military training, fearfully. I behaved as if she were a terrorist.”

That’s an interesting mental calculation on the part of some Israeli men: woman=terrorist.

At any rate, if you consider the guy claims he’s taking responsibility for his crime, why does he attempt such a ludicrous excuse for an argument?

“I take responsibility for the damage and pain I have caused,” he said. “I think about this every day, I know she experienced something terrible. Four or five months ago, I began psychological treatment as part of taking responsibility, in order to understand how I reached this state. My life was completely overturned. Her pain is what is most important, and I am trying to comprehend.”

What part of his psychological treatment included coming up with this bone-headed piece of junk defense theory?

On a related front, Dena Shunra even wonders whether Yoav Even may’ve learned his penchant for sodomy through his IDF service.  Perhaps he took one look at P’s dark form in his apartment that fateful night, mistook her for a terrorist, and the gut instincts instilled in him by his IDF training took over and he…sodomized her.

This may be a new tactic the Israeli army is developing.  In addition to F-16s and Apaches, it’s adding sodomy to its arsenal.

Supreme Court Reopens Israel’s Guantanamo

Friday, January 21st, 2011
camp 1391

Israel's notorious Camp 1391 torture prison

If you’ve ever heard Alan Dershowitz or any liberal Zionist talk about the wonderful role played by the Israeli High Court in protecting democracy and human rights in Israel, do me a favor and quote ‘em this post I’m writing.  I’m sorry to say that the Supreme Court is little more than a sham; window dressing allowing the State to say it has a supreme judicial body like other western democracies, while its Court is enfeebled and subservient to the interest of the national security state.

The Supreme Court today overturned an injunction secured by the Israeli human rights NGO, HaMoked and former MK Zahava Gal-On, which had closed a top-secret Israeli prison used for the detention and interrogation of high-value foreign prisoners (aka “enemy combatants”).  The prison, known only by its number, Unit 1391, is located within a secret Israeli military base called Camp Shlomo (after the name of a former commander of the IDF 504 intelligence unit) near Kibbutz Barkai.  Chris McGreal wrote about the detention camp here.  Dan Ephron wrote this about it in 2004:

What [Israeli historian Gad] Kroizer had discovered…was the location of an ultrasecret jail where Israel has held Arabs in total seclusion for years, barred visits by the Red Cross and allegedly tortured inmates. Known as 1391, the facility is used as an interrogation center by a storied unit of Israel’s military intelligence, whose members–all Arabic speakers–are trained to wring confessions from the toughest militants. According to Arabs who’ve been imprisoned in 1391, some of the methods are reminiscent of Abu Ghraib: nudity as a humiliation tactic, compromising photographs, sleep deprivation. In a few cases, at least, interrogators at 1391 appear to have gone beyond Israel’s own hair-splitting distinction between torture and what a state commission referred to in 1987 as “moderate physical pressure.”

secret idf prison camp 1391

Google Earth view of Israel's secret torture prison, Camp 1391, next door to Kibbutz Barkai

Let’s call it Israel’s Guantanamo as Jonathan Cook has.

What’s faintly humorous is that Maariv’s coverage of this story makes a major flourish over the secrecy of the military base, when most knowledgeable Israelis know everything I wrote above.  They just can’t write it in a newspaper or say it on TV or radio.

The prison is most notorious for the ‘hospitality’ enjoyed there by a Hezbollah operative it housed for eight years, Mustafa Dirani.  Dirani was sodomized at Unit 1391 by IDF military intelligence interrogators under the command of Doron Zahavi.  Later Dirani sued the State, won a large monetary settlement and his freedom.  His cousin, arrested with him, wasn’t so lucky.  As a result of his torture, he developed catatonic schizophrenia according to Jonathan Cooke.  Zahavi, who surely would’ve been promoted without the glare of publicity shined by the court suit, was drummed out of the IDF only to surface last year as the new Arab liaison for the Israeli police with special responsibilities to ensure the safe Judaization of East Jerusalem (though that’s not how the police describe his job).

This blog exposed Zahavi’s identity, because the country has a quaint tradition of refusing to identify anyone publicly who’s ever been an intelligence agent, even if they’re dead.  To Israelis he’s simply known as “Captain George.”  I thought that rather ridiculous and that Israel deserved to know the real name of someone who’s engaged in such heroic acts on behalf of his country.

As if all this history wasn’t bad enough, Maariv portrays the maddening legal contortions used by the justices for approving Israel’s latest torture facility.  We are supposed to feel reassured because the Court placed “meaningful” limits on use of the facility.  It is now only to be used to house foreign prisoners (no Israelis or Palestinians) and only for the limited period of a few days (Dirani was imprisoned there for eight years).  Prisoners will be entitled to visits from their attorneys and international organizations “except insofar as this shall be limited by the needs of the investigation according to the conditions of the law” (a loophole wide enough to drive a Mack truck through).  In order to detain a prisoner there, the IDF will have to notify the government’s legal advisor of his identity.  The judges also directed visitation rights for government and parliamentary delegations “under certain circumstances” (unspecified, natch).  These visiting bodies will have authority over the conditions under which detainees are held and ensure they are compatible with the law.  Only members of the Knesset intelligence subcommittee will be entitled to participate in these visits (and certainly no one from Zahava Gal On’s party, Meretz).

The justices wrote without a hint of irony:

“We believe that this will provide an appropriate balance enabling parliamentary visits without undermining security considerations which provide the reason for guarding the secrecy of the facility.”

The Court chief justice, Dorit Beinisch, emphasized that the examples provided by the complainants of secret prisons in Eastern Europe to which prisoners were brought through secret rendition were “a very great distance from the matter before it.”  She rejected the claim by HaMoked that the secrecy of the location of the prison violated international law saying that the holding of prisoners in detention there would fall under the rules of Israeli and international law.

While the complainants criticized the physical conditions under which the prisoners would be held and the methods of interrogation which would be used, the State claimed that conditions of detentions would be compatible with the law.  The government also rejected the claim that forbidden forms of interrogation would be utilized (saying this with a straight face after the Dirani affair beggars belief) except for the fact that prisoners would be blindfolded when transferred there.

The government claimed that the secrecy of Unit 1391 would not detract from the prisoners’ rights (except when they’re being tortured or deprived of attorney-client visits during those times when “conditions of the investigation” simply didn’t permit them).  The State offered to notify family of the detainee/victim of their detention, but would not provide the location of the facility.  Instead it would offer an “address” to which family could turn with its requests.  The authorities argued that providing such notice to the attorney would fulfill its obligations.

At a time when the U.S. has abandoned extraordinary rendition and drastically reduced the prisoner population at Guantanamo in an attempt to close it, it’s rather extraordinary that Israel’s Supreme Court is backpedaling on human rights and reopening one of Israel’s most notorious torture chambers.  Further, unlike Guantanamo which at least has a known physical address, no Israeli officially knows where the Unit 1391 prison is.

Saying that members of the parliamentary intelligence committee would provide sufficient oversight to ensure protection of the rights of the prisoners is like saying that the House intelligence committee provided sufficient oversight over CIA participation in waterboarding and extraordinary rendition.  Again, it simply beggars belief.  This from the “Only Democracy in the Middle East.”

Rabbi Rotter’s Son, Undercover Jerusalem Police Officer, Incites Violence Against Sheikh Jarrah Protesters

Sunday, January 16th, 2011
meir rotter

Meir Rotter, undercover police officer publicly advocates violence against Sheikh Jarrah protestors

For those not steeped in Israeli culture, there is an online forum called Rotter that plays a unique role in certain segments of Israeli society.  It’s a cross between FoxNews, Matt Drudge, DebkaFiles and NewsMax.  It is a wildly popular internet forum (Alexa ranks it 83rd in Israel) that deals in everything from celebrity gossip to political scoops and intelligence matters, all with a far-right political focus.  It’s especially known for its brand of vituperative, scabrous political debate, sorta like the Jerusalem Post talkbacks on steroids.  I’m routinely called “Terrorist” there as if it were my first name, which I wear of course as a badge of courage.

meir rotter leads west bank hike

Meir Rotter (note blue knitted skullcap) leading West Bank hike

Rotter.net was founded in 1999 by Rabbi Yeshayahu Rotter, who now runs the site with at least a few of his children helping administer and moderate it.  Meir Rotter, 37, married and the father of two, is Yeshayahu’s son and serves as a police officer in Jerusalem.  In a Wikipedia discussion, his sister Tamar confirms that her brother is a police officer.

He is a fixture at the weekly Sheikh Jarrah demonstrations where he’s been assigned for the past six months.  You can see him “in action” toward the end of this Sheikh Jarrah video in which he steals a Palestinian flag from the hands of an Israeli demonstrator.  He’s known to be a particularly nasty, odious presence wearing his enormous blue settler-style skullcap, wraparound sunglasses, and a pistol strapped to his waist (see picture).  Since he never wears a police uniform at the protests, he would appear to be a plain clothes officer.  Frankly, I can’t quite figure out why he’d be there in plain clothes dressed as a settler.  He wouldn’t be fooling anyone.

Most of this could be figured out pretty easily using public and online records.  But what is hitherto unknown is that an Israeli source tells me that Meir Rotter is not only an administrator of Rotter, but a member who posts under the name Kafe, some of the most offensive material inciting violence against the Sheikh Jarrah demonstrators.  He routinely calls them “leftist fascist, anti-Zionist, post-Israeli.”  That Meir Rotter is a police officer isn’t news.  That a Rotter administrator posts material advocating violence against lawful Israeli citizens isn’t news either.  But the fact that a police officer paid by the Jerusalem municipality ostensibly to enforce the law and keep the peace speaks of knives and axes as “legitimate means of  protest” should open a few eyes somewhere.

It certainly won’t open the eyes of Doron Zahavi, the former IDF torturer of Mustafa Dirani, who is the now the Jerusalem police “liaison” to the East Jerusalem Arab community.  Undoubtedly, Zahavi and Rotter work together, perhaps in the same unit.  Perhaps Zahavi is teaching Rotter a thing or two about torturing Arabs, just as the former’s subordinates sodomized Dirani in an Israeli prison several years ago.

There is compelling evidence to support the claim that Kafe and Rotter fils are one and the same person.  First, Kafe was one of the earliest members to sign up for the forum (on October 21, 2001) just after it was revamped in the format it presently has.  Second, for the past seven months many of his posts deal with the Sheikh Jarrah protests and police affairs related to them.  In particular, they often deal with intelligence about either the Israeli protestors or the East Jerusalem Arab community.  This is intelligence that would only be available or even interesting to either a police officer or a Shabak agent.

The image above on the right is from one of the hikes Rotter leads in the West Bank for his religious-nationalist acolytes.  Here one of the participants names Rotter and refers to pictures that he took on one of these hikes.  Another gallery on the same Picasa account displays images of Rotter himself (see right-hand image above) leading the hikes.

There is another stylistic element of Rotter’s writing that nails his identity as Kafe.  In Wikipedia, he writes (in Hebrew) under his own name:

Often the number in Shomron reaches into the hundreds! of hikers.

In Rotter, he writes as Kafe:

Every day, my dear friend receives free, at no cost! these two newspapers at the doorstep of his home.

meir rotter violent post

Meir Rotter advocates spraying Sheikh Jarrah protesters with yellow paint

I’d say it’s a pretty rare thing for two different people to place exclamation marks in the middle of sentences as Rotter has done here.  Using brackets [!] would not be unusual, but unbracketed is highly so.

I think the State might take an interest that one of its police officers is writing material like the following.  Keep in mind that these are entirely non-violent demonstrations at which the only violence comes from the side of the police:

We should bring some yellow spray paint and spray the rioting anarchists and their band of left-wing fascists who join and even lead them.  With the slogan: “Paint the traitors yellow [the color of cowardice], we’ll tar and feather ‘em for the traitors against their people and terrorists against the state that they are.

Since axes, knives and clubs are a legitimate form of protest, spray paint will be my favorite weapon.

meir rotter violent post

Meir Rotter's forum post advocating rock-throwing and damaging vehicles of Sheikh Jarrah protesters

Or that he here advocates stoning protestors and vandalizing their property.  Keep in mind that there is never any violence of any kind at the Friday Sheikh Jarrah protest except that perpetrated by the police against the protesters:

The anarchists view it as suitable to express their protests using massive stones thrown at vehicles, homes and people [in Sheikh Jarrah], why should we not wait for them at the exit of the village and take the same form of protest to them and their vehicles.  Why wouldn’t they think that legitimate?

At last Friday’s Sheikh Jarrah protest, my source reveals that Officer Rotter “brutally assaulted” three demonstrators.  It sounds like he’s a very loose cannon prone to do some serious and personal damage if not reined in.

Here (Hebrew original) our favorite officer of the law even lumps the policies of the Israeli government with those of the “anarchists” and radical Islamists:

Not all is rosy in East Jerusalem.  The policy of the Israeli government itself, along with the activism of the leftist-fascist-anarchists in the eastern part of the city, and including the unceasing attempts by the PA and/or the Islamic Movement –they all cause severe harm to the control of the State of Israel over Jerusalem.  The topic of what the Arabs really want [to destroy Israel] is never broached in  Israeli [political] discussion.

Kafe advocates an iron hand against the Palestinian community.  He suggests that protests must be isolated to the Arab villages and not be allowed to spread to the streets of the city.  His ultimate goal is that the Jewish residents of the city never even hear about the protests in their own city except in the media.  The price, if there is any, will be paid by the Arabs themselves who will harm, or so he claims, only themselves and not the city’s Jewish residents.

Rotter seems obsessed with the notion that the protests might spread outside East Jerusalem and infect Jewish neighborhoods.  That would be, in his fervid imagination, making the mistake that any government makes when faced with civil unrest and chaotic conditions.  If you engage even a moment’s doubt and fail to use every means at your disposal to violently clamp down, you will find the bastards running down your own street committing acts of hooliganism and God knows what to Jews.  Before you know it you’ll have anarchy and Arabs taking over the country.

Rotter/Kafe is contemptuous of the gutless Israeli media (Hebrew original):

Once again, the Israeli media in its true ugliness and degradation

It’s no secret that the Israeli media, by and large, is precisely like the UN, hypocrites, anti-Zionist, post-Israeli.  A megaphone and platform for the extreme leftist-anarchist agenda.  Yes, yes, they’ll deny it and say that anyone making such a claim is a fascist, someone who suppresses democratic rights and shuts people up.  They say that their role must be to expose and question and all sorts of bullshit coming from their demagogic lips.

In a survey of media coverage of Sheikh Jarrah we find not just hypocritical lies and falsification of facts, because the tendency in such coverage is toward a post-Israel, anti-Zionist, racist ideology which negates the rights of Jews to the Land of Israel

In a later portion of the same post, he brags that he persuaded a good friend to cancel the two subscriptions to Israeli daily newspapers which he had.  One was to Haaretz.  He didn’t specify the name of the other but it would either be Maariv or Yediot Achronot.  It is an indication of just how radical his political views are that he cast scorn even on these two dailies known for their right-of-center reporting.

UPDATE: Earlier today, Meir Rotter posted a reply to this post at an Israeli police officer’s online forum in which he acknowledged that he is an officer assigned to Sheikh Jarrah and that he is Rabbi Rotter’s son.  He denies that he is a moderator of the Rotter forum (because his father won’t pay him!).  But he specifically does not either mention or deny the most important claim of my source, that he is the Rotter member, Kafe.  There is a principle in the law: “silence is assent.”  It applies here.

I’m afraid my source may’ve passed this information on to me because s/he was afraid that if it was revealed in Israel alone Meir Rotter might receive a promotion, instead of being disciplined.  At least, if a foreign media source reports the matter, it may be treated as more than a curiosity.

It will surprise no one that the Jerusalem police force harbors in its midst violent radical settler thugs.  But it may surprise Israelis that such individuals will express their venom, hate and rage in such a public setting.  A question for the police superintendent to ponder: is he comfortable with his officers publicly advocating violence against peacefully, legally protesting Israeli citizens?  Is that the standard of law his personnel uphold?

Identity of Former IDF Torturer Exposed, ‘Captain George’ is Doron Zahavi

Thursday, July 29th, 2010
doron zahavi captain george

Alleged Arab torturer Doron Zahavi aka 'Captain George' (Haaretz)

Yesterday, I reported here on a Haaretz story about the notorious “Captain George,” an IDF military intelligence interrogator accused in 2004 of sodomizing a Lebanese kidnap victim in order to secure information about the location of IDF officer, Ron Arad.  Among the things I wrote was my complaint that Haaretz was protecting the real identity of George even though he no longer served in military intelligence.

With the help of a diligent Israeli researcher, I can now expose George’s real identity.  He is Doron Zahavi, currently the Arab affairs liaison for the Jerusalem police.  His job, as I noted yesterday, is to direct community relations and liaison efforts between the police and Jerusalem’s Arab residents.

In discussing the parameters of Zahavi’s job, a police spokesperson told Haaretz:

“The adviser must be an accepted and welcome figure in the Arab community, with excellent interpersonal skills – someone they feel they can trust, otherwise he cannot succeed in the job,” a senior police officer said.

doron zahavi exposed

ACRI complaint identifies Doron Zahavi by name

Apparently, Zahavi has performed his job so well he’s garnering rave reviews right and left from his Arab interlocutors.  One, Jouad Siam, complained that in a February, 2010 interrogation, Zahavi threatened to destroy his home (Hebrew source) unless he disbanded a Silwan information center Siam had founded to counter the building efforts of settlers in his neigborhood.  Here is how the ex-torturer now conducts himself.  I’ll let you be the judge whether the leopard has changed his spots:

He [Zahavi] told us we were making problems and we had to close the center.  I told him: “I thought we are in a democracy.”  This raised the ire of ‘George,’ who said: “We Jews are fools.  We treat you too well.  I thought you would behave yourself.”  ’George’ threatened that he would draw up a demolition order for his home if he refused to close the center.

According to Siam, “The entire conversation was conducted in shouts.  He didn’t let me speak.  He would ask and answer his own questions [without allowing Siam to respond].  At the end of the discussion, he told me to go home and behave myself.

Last February, the Association for Civil Right in Israel registered a formal complaint against Zahavi for his outburst.  Among the claims listed was that Zahavi called Siam a “criminal” and said that the latter would be held responsible for everything that happened in Silwan.  The interrogator asked about the source of Siam’s income and told him he would intervene with his boss.  At the end of the meeting, Zahavi attempted to enlist Siam as an informant.

The police replied formally to the complaint claiming laughably that Zahavi had merely invited Siam to a “get to know you” meeting in which the police advisor sought to discover what issues particularly troubled the local Arab population.  In the course of the meeting, Zahavi felt it necessary to inform his Arab interlocutor about activities in which he was engaged that violated the law.  No mention in the police reply how founding an information center was a violation of law.

The publicly available ACRI complaint lists Zahavi’s real name.  In that case, why would Haaretz not be able to use it?  The whole situation baffles me.  At any rate, thank God we’re not bound by any such nonsense and we offer the real Doron Zahavi to the world in all his glory.  If a reader has a picture of Zahavi, please let me know.

Sacked IDF Torturer to Direct Police Relations With East Jerusalem Arabs

Tuesday, July 27th, 2010
idf soldier abuses 8 year old palestinian

The 'Captain George' treatment for Arabs--here an 8 year old boy is abused by an IDF soldier

captain george israeli torturer

Blurred image of Captain George, the accused Israeli torturer (Haaretz)

If anyone ever wants to know why relations between Israel and the Arabs are so incredibly messed up, you have but to examine the story I’m about to tell.  It will show you that Israel’s police, military and political leader are clueless when it comes to really understanding their Arab neighbors.  In fact, one could say that decisions like the one described below indicate that Israel doesn’t want to understand Arabs, but rather wants to dominate them by force and even torture if necessary.

In 1994, the IDF kidnapped the alleged chief of security for Amal because he was believed to have held captured IDF Capt. Ran Arad for two years.  They spirited Dirani to Israel for questioning.   He was held for eight years.  Mustafa Dirani afterward alleged that he was continuously tortured for one month by soldiers under the command of a “Captain George.”  (For the life of me I can’t understand why Haaretz can’t fully identify a man who is now nothing but a police officer.  Does his former status as a military intelligence officer confer lifetime anonymity?  Or would revealing his identity reopen the embarrassing story of torture at Camp 1391?)

Here is how the victim described his treatment:

In 2004, he testified in court about being raped with a baton by soldiers under “George’s” command.  Dirani said he was threatened not to reveal what had happened to him, had suffered continuous torture for a month and throughout that period was not allowed any clothes, only adult diapers.

“George” denied Dirani’s claims, except to confirm that one soldier had been sent into the prisoner’s cell wearing only underwear to threaten him with a sexual act. The Military Police investigation did not result in an indictment.

George was a senior office in Unit 504 of IDF military intelligence.  He served at the notorious top-secret military torture facility (Abu Graibh anyone?) called Camp 1391 located near Kibbutz Barkai.  The prison became so notorious that Israel closed it down.  But not before the damage it did to Dirani and countless others.  If you read Hebrew, you can regale yourself with the full panoply of torture techniques used by George and his boys there.

Dirani sued Israel for $1.5-million, but subsequently was released and left Israel.   And poor Captain George was sacked.  Unfortunately, the case is now dormant.

But here’s the kicker.  Capt. George left military service and transferred to the Israeli police, where he was just promoted to be the official liaison between the Jerusalem police force and the city’s Arab community.  So get this, an intelligence agent accused of conducting the brutal torture interrogation of an Arab is now performing a job described thus:

“The adviser must be an accepted and welcome figure in the Arab community, with excellent interpersonal skills – someone they feel they can trust, otherwise he cannot succeed in the job,” a senior police officer said.

Given his reputation as a butcher, the police appear highly satisfied with his work so far:

The police said: “There is no link between the previous role held by Major D. ["George"] and his current position. The officer is carrying out his duties to Franco’s satisfaction, and is contributing a great deal to the good relationship between Jerusalem police and the Arabs of East Jerusalem.”

You bet there’s a link.  He was a torturer before and he’ll be a torturer again.  If the police think this man can have anything but a bitter relationship with any self-respecting Arab in East Jerusalem, they’ve taken leave of their senses.  But the statement above is window-dressing.  What the police really want George to do is be as brutal with the local Arabs as he was with the Hezbollah prisoner.  Brutality.  That is what wins awards as far as Israel is concerned.  The Arabs according to this code can’t be reasoned with.  They can only be dominated.  Weakness is death.  Overwhelming force commands respect.  That’s the ethos of Captain George and his fellow torturers.

And this, in a nutshell, is why there has not been peace and may never be peace between the two peoples.

Enhanced by Zemanta
Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE