Mahzor

New York Public Library

Churches

Sarajevo Haggadah

Mah Nishtanah

Sarajevo haggadah

Antaea Darom

Israeli women's art

Action

Torah as music

Ben Heine

Action

ceramic bowl

Mohammad Said Kalash, "Offering Reconciliation" exhibit (photo: Ilan Amihai)

Action

Punch and Judy/Pinchas and Jamila

Avi Katz

Action

David Grossman

Ben Heine

Action

Eldrige Street shul

Lower East Side

Action

Dove

Ben Heine

Action

Two birds

Hoda Jamal

Action

Israeli and Palestinian boys

from documentary, Promises

Action

Cat in the Hat

Yiddish version

Action

Daylight through the Wall

Banksy: graffiti art on Separation Wall

Action

Maurice Sendak's Brundibar set

New Victory Theater (photo: Nan Melville/NYT)

Action

Daniel Barenboim, West-Eastern Divan Orchestra

Palestinian-Israeli musical ensemble (photo: Kerstin Joensson/AP)

Action

Great Day on Eldrige Street

N.Y.'s klezmer greats celebrate shul rededication (photo: Leo Sorel)

Action

Joint Appeal for Peace

(Avi Katz)

Joint Appeal for Peace

Ketubah, Ancona, Italy (1772)

(Jewish Theological Seminary library)

Ancona ketubah

Archive for December, 2010

Isaiah Weeps: Jewish National Fund, GOD-TV Erase Israeli Bedouin Village to Bring Jesus’ Second Coming

Monday, December 6th, 2010
god tv jewish national fund forest erases bedouin village

Sign celebrating GOD-TV/Jewish National Fund forest eradicating Bedouin village, Al Araqib

After researching this post and watching the video transcribed below, I don’t know whether to cry or scream at the grievous injustices done to Israel’s Bedouin in the name of the Jewish people (the Jewish National Fund) and Christians the world over (GOD-TV).

The Israeli government is hoping the seventh time is the charm in their efforts to eradicate the Israeli Bedouin village of Al-Araqib.  That’s how many times they’re destroyed it only to have its inhabitants return and rebuild it once more.  In fact, the steadfastness of these indigenous residents of the Negev reminds me of the Biblical Prophets exhorting the Jews to cling to their Land no matter what evil befalls them.

Now, Israeli State thieves have come upon a new scam to make the destruction of the place more thorough and long-lasting.  They’ve enlisted the Jewish National Fund, whose forests have already disappeared hundreds of former Israeli Palestinian villages uprooted during the Nakba.  JNF together with the Israel Lands Administration which claims the Bedouin land on behalf of the State,  brought their bulldozers to plant a new forest that will cover the ground on which Al-Araqib stands.  As if that wasn’t shocking enough, JNF’s partner in this crimes is even more astonishing: the Christian Zionist evangelical GOD-TV.

Neve Gordon just wrote about this in The Nation and suggested I do further research and publish on this tragedy.  I also commend the activism of the Negev Coexistence Forum, which is fighting the good fight on behalf of Al Araqib’s rightful residents.

Those who read this blog know I wrote several posts on the destruction of the village a few weeks ago by thousands of Israeli Border Police along with armored vehicles.  The devastation of this place, which has been the residents’ home for generations, and going back much earlier than the creation of the State in 1948, is worse than a tragedy.  It is truly an evil deed hatched by a nation calling itself a Jewish state, thus deprecating, even figuratively disappearing its non-Jewish citizens.

al araqib burned

What you won't see on GOD-TV: Al Araqib residents resist Israeli government efforts to eradicate their village

Now, Israel feels it needs to add a final exclamation point to its efforts to wipe out Al Araqib.  It will no longer need to demolish the village every few weeks once a forest grows and subsumes any civilization that once existed there.  It will be like the thick Central American jungle blotting out the Mayan ruins to the naked eye centuries after the magnificent cities were emptied of their inhabitants by flood, fire or other disaster.

Planting a forest on the site of a Palestinian Israeli village is a tried and true tactic used by the early Israeli state to eradicate remnants of Palestinian civilization lost to the Nakba, when 750,000 Israeli Palestinians were expelled just before and during what is commonly known as the War of Independence.  Today’s Zionist JNF/ILA apparatchiks seem to think the same ploy will work in the Negev.  But it won’t and can’t because the whole world (or least this blog and its readers) is watching.  When the world watches evil unfold it cannot take hold as firmly and deeply.  We know where evil lies and we can uproot it at a future time.  We will not forget Al Araqib nor those who violently wiped away its existence.  The evil they do will follow them; or at least we will.

If anyone needed evidence of the fact that the nationalists extremists running this Israeli government have made unholy alliance with Christian Zionist extremists, there can be no better example than this.  This sign proudly erected a few hundred feet from where Al Araqib lies boasts not only that GOD-TV is partnering with the JNF is destroying a Bedouin community–it has the chutzpah to quote Isaiah.  This brilliant prophet committed to justice and morality is being exploited to whitewash pure evil.  It would make the man who proclaimed these words cry out in his anger and his shame:

isaiah

The prophet Isaiah weeps: woe unto evangelicals 'who call evil good.'

Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil.

Then said I, Woe is me! for I am undone; because I am a man of unclean lips, and I dwell in the midst of a people of unclean lips.

What do you mean by beating my people to pieces, and grinding the faces of the poor?

He looked for judgement, but behold oppression; for righteousness, but behold a cry.

When you see images of the young, green saplings planted by JNF juxtapose this image with the following news of the devastation the Israeli government wrought in 2004 on these same fields when they were planted and harvested by the native Bedouin:

…The authorities stepped up the pressure on the Araqib to leave by spraying powerful herbicides on their crops, making the young shoots shrivel and die in the following weeks.  It was the third time the Araqib’s crops had been sprayed in the past two years by a government agency, the Israel Lands Authority.

“This time we hurriedly took what crops we could for feed,” says Abu Darim. “We made the mistake of giving them to our animals. Nearly 400 of the sheep miscarried.”

The recent campaign of crop-spraying by the authorities – more than 6000 acres have been destroyed over a wide area of the Negev in the last two years – is not the only weapon being used by the state.

Over the past 12 months, there has also been a wave of house demolitions, making nearly 2000 bedouin homeless. At least three mosques have also been destroyed.

It seems the good Christian folk at GOD-TV don’t want just anyone making the desert bloom.  They want only Jews to do so.  Bedouin are the wrong sort of people for them.

If you read the GOD-TV site, you’ll find the convenient and miraculous discovery of an ancient Christian monastery in an internal Israeli settlement dubbed Givot Bar:

While clearing land as part of Israel’s project to reclaim the desert as suitable residential ground, a buried ‘world’ was unveiled. This historical gem has revealed buildings and artifacts from an ancient Christian community who lived in the Holy Land over 1500 years ago! This location is where some of the first Christian gathered to worship God. At Givot Bar in the Negev stands an old Farmhouse and Byzantine Church building – from as early as the 6th Century. Historical artifacts like an ancient wine-press and water cistern also point to a lifestyle of centuries gone by.

Such a “discovery” mirrors similar archaeological finds at digs in Silwan and other Arab communities which the far right settlement movement wishes to expel for political purposes to establish Jewish presence and supremacy.  This is the use of history and archaeology to settle political disputes.  Similary, Givot Bar is nothing more than an internal Israeli settlement meant to displace not Palestinians as in the West Bank, but indigenous Israeli Bedouin, citizens of the State of Israel.

Cook notes that the Al Araqib destruction is part of a larger government effort to consolidate Bedouin in large central population centers so that Jewish settlements can take their place:

…A government plan, personally approved a year ago by Prime Minister Ariel Sharon and backed by $200 million, [will] force the rural Bedouin off their lands and into a handful of urban reservations the state is building for them.

…The stakes are high. The government wants the huge land reservoir of the Negev - two-thirds of Israel’s total territory -for Jewish immigration over the coming decades, and possibly for settlers evacuated from the West Bank and Gaza if peace ever arrives.

In 2002 the World Zionist Organisation (WZO) announced plans to start building settlements to bring 350,000 Jewish immigrants to the Galilee and the Negev the first time the WZO has funded settlements outside the occupied Palestinian territories in 26 years.

…If the Bedouin can be forced out of their villages, their place will be taken by 14 exclusive Jewish settlements and dozens more private farmsteads, modelled on Sharon’s own huge agricultural estate in the Negev, known as Sycamore Ranch.

This phenomenon provides proof that the Israeli Occupation isn’t the only injustice perpetrated by the State, but that Israel citizens too suffer.  The expulsion of the Bedouin is a contemporary iteration of the Nakba meant to reinforce the supremacy of Israel’s Jewish citizens.

Who has the JNF made common cause with?  GOD-TV, a group which in 2009 gave JNF $500,000 for this forest (IRS 990 pdf) as preparation for Jesus’ return.  This is precisely how the project is described in the group’s IRS 990 form:

“The grant to the Jewish National Fund was to plant trees in Israel, to participate in dressing the Holy Land for the return of Jesus.”

In other words, world Jewry is embracing a group which is aiding evangelical radicals in their goal of bringing about the Second Coming of Jesus.  Is this why we collected coins in our blue JNF pushkes in Hebrew school lo those many years ago?

god-tv Rory and Bo Praying

Rory Alec and Bo 'preparing to dress the Holy Land' with trees 'for Jesus' Return'

Now, let’s read excerpts of the transcript of the following video that GOD-TV’s owner-host Rory Alec (legal name, Rory A. Stephen) made on the site of Al Araqib, all the while never mentioning a word about this eradicated Bedouin village on whose lands he stood:

[Camera pans over hills of Al Araqib as Rory Alec comes into view.  Superimposed on his image is a full-frame Israeli flag waving as he addresses the camera]

It’s quite amazing Precious One how the Lord has led us as a ministry, GOD-TV, to connect with this land, this land that God loves so much.

…[Alec gives a summary of Jewish history refracted through evangelical theology ending with the expulsion of Jews from their land].  And then the prophets describe something extraordinary, how God will bring His people back to what has become a barren land. In 1948, we see something extraordinary in the history of the nations of the earth, where a majority of the United Nations agree after much prayer, and of course the prophecy is fulfilled and the land is reborn in a day.  The nation in May 1948.

Here we are in the Negev [Alec turns to look at the surrounding landscape] and something the Lord put in my spirit, an instruction from God which was, “Rory and Wendy,” (we’re the God TV family) “prepare the land for the return of my Son.” And my spirit jumped and I said “Father in heaven, how do we do that?”  And the Lord said to us, and this was three or four years ago, “Plant a million trees.”

I believe that’s what I heard the spirit of God, in a still small voice, say to us.  And we shared that with you and I remember…we said for every gift…you’d send in, we would thank you for your gift by representing you and your family with this little tree, with a little sapling.  Well, welcome to the God TV Forest and Bo this is amazing.  [Rory, reading Isaiah 41:18 from JNF’s God TV Forest sign],  “I will turn the deserts into pools of water, and the parched ground into springs.”

This is the beginning of, my goodness, right across Israel, how many trees have we planted so far?…

Bo Sander:  So far we have planted in the ground about a half a million trees, half a million trees…

You know, Saints (addressing television audience), the extraordinary thing is the Lord put it in our spirits that we should plant a million trees to prepare the land for the return of his Son, and I tell you Jesus is coming back soon!  This ministry is about a billion souls, and you and I will be fired up and stirred up to go out and share Jesus…He’s coming back and the Lord is saying to us, the God TV family, prepare the land and this is the land that needs preparing.  This is the desert, brother!

Bo:   It is wonderful and you know, this is where his people [Jews returning to Israel] are going to stay when they come.  And the Scripture also says…that the desert needs to grow and develop, because His people are coming back.  This is aliyah and the Jewish people are coming back to the land, and they need to have a place to stay and to live.  And this is part of the development of the land, and this is scripture being fulfilled.

Rory:  In front of us…And I know some of you are skeptical about Israel.  Not everything the government of Israel does is correct, but you and I have been instructed by God Almighty to stand in the gap, to be watchmen on the walls of Jerusalem, so to speak, to intercede and to pray for.  And God does declare in his Word, his sovereign unchangeable Word, that he who blesses Abraham, he who blesses the seed of Abraham, he who blesses the land that God has promised and given, he who blesses the Jewish people – Israel and Judah – God will bless them, irrespective of what the Israelites or the Israelis are doing.  We are praying for salvation, we are praying for blessing.  But you and I have been instructed, as the body of Yeshua, to stand in the gap, and intercede that the divine will of God takes place in this nation, this miraculous nation…

Bo: I just want to emphasize what you and our viewers at GOD-TV have done here in Israel.  It’s so appreciated.  And the government here, the Jewish National Fund, Land of Promise, the Givot Bar village here, all of them are super-excited about what is happening here.  How we can come in and support them and help them in this very difficult time. It’s just so wonderful to see.

Rory: You and I are bringing life in all its forms…you and I are fulfilling a prophecy that was declared by Hosiah and Ezechiel and Hez…literally the whole shebang.  We are being obedient in the hands of the Lord.  We are His hands, His heart, His…we’re preparing the land by His spirit…

Everyone who gives a red cent to this outfit should know that it is displacing the legitimate, indigenous inhabitants of this land, the Bedouin.  And lest donors not care, let’s point out to the Internal Revenue Service that GOD-TV’s 501c3 entity, the Angel Christian Television Trust, Inc., gives the heksher of the U.S. government to these evangelical fanatic efforts to root out Israeli inhabitants of this land.  That means that once again the Obama administration is allowing U.S. non profits to undermine express U.S. policy toward Israel through supporting the violent supplanting of Israel’s inhabitants by a forest.  Speaking about donations, Angel Christian TV’s 2009 990 notes that Rory and his wife Wendy earned approximately $450,000 that year.  Flogging Jesus in the Holy Land is nice work if you can get it.

Lest this transcript hasn’t shocked you enough, let’s tell you a bit more about GOD-TV and its fanatical bedfellows.  Some of the most popular stars of this evangelical media enterprise are Joyce Meyer, Creflo Dollar, Benny Hinn,  and Kenneth Copeland, founders of the Prosperity Gospel movement, who in 2007 were under investigation by Sen. Charles Grassley for using their non-profit status to “shield their lavish lifestyle.”

According to Rachel Tabachnick, one of the closest students of evangelical theology, GOD-TV embraces not just Dispensationalist theology, which is a more quiescent form of evangelism, but a far more aggressive and radical evangelism:

God TV does feature Dispensationalists, but the network also promotes another more aggressive and more virulent End Times theology that is becoming dominant in Christian Zionist activism. This is what is sometimes known as “End Times warriors.”  This is NOT Dispensationalism – it is worse. Dispensationalism is passive to some extent because believers have to wait for the “Rapture”…for the End Times horrors to begin…In the End Times theology to which I was referring, there is no waiting for the Rapture and humans have the mandate to advance the End Times.

God TV features New Apostolic leaders who call themselves “apostles and prophets,” and who reject Dispensationalism…It does not yet have a convenient label, but is a mid-Tribulation or post-Tribulation premillennialism…a form of “Dominion” theology that requires Christians to take supremacy over the earth before Jesus can return…

This helps to explain how Christian Zionist leaders like John Hagee are getting away with claiming that their End Times prophecy is benign and Jewish leaders shouldn’t be concerned.  In the Dispensational timeline the reign of the Antichrist, apocalyptic battles, suffering of the Jews, and other horrors of the Tribulation period don’t begin until after the born again believers are “Raptured” or snatched from the earth.  They have to wait…for this divine intervention.  Jewish leaders who embrace Hagee say that they don’t believe this will ever take place, so there’s nothing to worry about.  No Rapture, no Tribulation, no problem.  But most of John Hagee’s CUFI leaders and hosts are no longer Dispensational!  They have made the transition to the more aggressive theology in which believers can…advance the prophetic clock.

In this rapidly growing Dominionist theology, born again believers…fight the Antichrist and evil instead of watching from the grandstands of heaven…Many Charismatic evangelicals are being taught to forget about being Raptured and prepare to fight…This is one of the factors creating the current hysteria in the U.S. about the Antichrist and his one-world government and why conspiracy theories are so rampant. (Christian Identity and associated white supremacist groups have always rejected the Rapture and taught that they must prepare to fight.)

Rory and Wendy Alec, like most leading religious broadcasters are Charismatics.  In the Charismatic stream of evangelicalism, this…embrace of Dominionism is taking place at an incredible rate, taught largely by leaders calling themselves “apostles and prophets.”  Wendy Alec is a self-proclaimed prophet and she features apostles like Mike Bickle on GOD-TV regularly.  Bickle leads a movement called the International House of Prayer (IHOP) to train young people to be the End Times warriors who will be endowed with supernatural powers to purge the earth of evil (and convert Jews) and bring about Jesus’ return. IHOP’s “Israel Mandate” is part of a coordinated international effort to support Messianic Jewish ministries.  Unconverted Jews are viewed as blocking the Christian 1000-year utopia from taking place.  Christians United for Israel (CUFI) director Robert Stearns works with the “Israel Mandate” and is also co-founder of the Day of Prayer for the Peace of Jerusalem which has a similar agenda.

…God TV is…deeply immersed in apocalyptic narratives merged with “New World Order” conspiracy theories. Each year they run a series that last a couple of months called Apocalypse and the End Times featuring leading bible prophecy experts and conspiracy theorists claiming that the globe is under attack by a cabal of demonic forces/global elites…[It constitutes] ”New World Order” conspiracy theories being marketed as prophecy.  In short…1930s-style paranoid conspiracy theories with underlying anti-Semitic themes are being marketed internationally as End Times prophecy. GOD-TV is careful with their treatment of Jews and do not overtly include Jews in the demonic Illuminati/Masonic conspiracy, although Jews are clearly the target historically in these narratives, and almost all of these end times prophecy experts teach that the termination of Judaism is necessary prior to the Millennial Kingdom on earth.

This is the source of much of the fear and hysteria in our society about a one-world government, one-world currency, imminent loss of American sovereignty to the U.N. or foreign troops, Federal Reserve conspiracy theory, imprisoning Christian patriots in concentration camps, etc.

The Apocalypse and the End Times series has featured End Times prophecy experts including:

-Tim LaHaye, author of the Left Behind series with over 65 million copies sold

-Paul McGuire, well-known End Times prophecy writer /New World Order conspiracy theorist and professor at Jack Hayford’s Kings Seminary which also trains Messianics for the “redemption of all Israel”

-Mike Bickle, (see above). Lou Engle, who heads the anti-abortion, anti-gay “The Call” is also based at IHOP Kansas City with Bickle.

-Grant Jeffrey, End Times prophecy writer/New World Order conspiracy theorist, author of the “documentary” Shadow Government: How the Global Elite Plan to Destroy Your Democracy and Your Freedom.   Jeffrey was lead speaker along with Karl Rove at event in Toronto that was intended to parallel the G-20 Summit, hosted by Canada’s CUFI director.

-Chuck Missler, merges end times prophecy with alien/UFO conspiracies

God TV televised the revival of Todd Bentley held in Florida in the summer of 2008 which included kicking and head butting severely-ill people to expel the demons during faith healing ceremonies.  Bentley claimed that the revival was healing people from all over the world as well as reviving dead people. He is a heavily-tattooed former sex offender who has been embraced by the “apostles” as having special powers.

God TV televises “The Call” events of Lou Engle.  These are virulently anti-abortion and anti-gay but also stress proselytizing Israeli Jews.

Rory Alec’s wife, Wendy Alec, calls herself a “Prophet Evangelist.”  She writes a Christian fantasy series called the Chronicle of Brothers, which chronicles Lucifer’s fall from heaven and his campaign to contaminate the DNA of humanity.   It is heavily influenced by New World Order “theology” and conspiracy theories, which can be read in this passage which takes place on September 10, 2001 in front of the Council of the 13 Illuminati led by the Jesuit priest, Lorcan De Molay, who is contemplating the horrors of the following day:

“He surveyed the men seated before him.  The Council of Thirteen, the highest orders of the Committee of 300, the Black Nobility of Venice.  The Supreme Mother Council of the of the thirty-third-degree masons of the Scottish Rite.

He scanned the faces of the chairman of the Club of Rome, the Federal Reserve, the Bilderberger Group, the International Monetary Fund, the Bohemian Grove, the Lucius Trust, his gaze finally resting on the Frater Superior and Grand Tribunal of the Ordo Templi Orienti.

The Grand Masters of the Illuminati.

The secret Illuminati who controlled the American government.

Who controlled every government of the Eastern and Western world.

Who in turn were controlled by him.

Lorcan De Molay.”

When the Jewish National Fund and Israeli government lie down with dogs like this is there any doubt they’ll get up with fleas???  You make your bed, you lie in it.

Thank you to Rachel Tabachnik for helping transcribe the video and her research on GOD-TV.

Israeli Media Falsely Accuse Palestinians of Arson in Carmel Fire

Sunday, December 5th, 2010
carmel fire

If there were any justice, this would be Eli Yishai's political career going up in smoke (AFP)

The Israeli government hasbara brigade appears to have assigned several recruits to “monitor” this blog and publish official talking points here.  So I think it’s worthwhile to update yesterday’s post with the latest news developments and a few ripostes to the worst of the nonsense.

There is a meme running through the apologist comments–only a few nuts are blaming Israeli Palestinians for setting the fire.  To put that little baby to rest, let’s quote the Israeli media watchdog, 7th Eye, which writes:

Live coverage of the tragic Carmel fire contained negative stereotyping of ethnic minorities and the hurling of unconvincing accusations of guilt by the Interior Minister [Eli Yishai of the Shas Party] and other politicians representing the ultra-Orthodox and settlers.

…Those reporters broadcasting from the field emphasized in discussing the new fires which broke out in places that hadn’t previously been alight, that this was the result of arson.  They all quoted sources in the police or fire department which described these new conflagrations as taking advantage of efforts to fight the original fire.  The connotation was that those setting the new fires were taking advantage of the nation’s weakness to terrorize it and make conditions worse.  There was no doubt they were alluding to hostile acts by elements of the Arab community.  It never occurred to a single one of these correspondents that the wave of fires was not the result of evil intent by a fifth column…

During the reporting on the causes of the Carmel fire, from the first moment radio and TV disseminated reports that hinted it was the result of deliberate acts by residents of [the Israeli Druze village] Isfiya….On Channel 10, a [Jewish] survivor of the fire said: “We’re lost.  Everything of ours is burned.  Everything is alight behind me.  They’ve been trying to burn us down for some time.  Now, they’ve succeeded.

There was no doubt what he meant.  That the Druze residents brought this disaster on the State.  And they did it deliberately.  No one at Channel 10 corrected him and pointed out that this serious charge was unfounded…

Haaretz confirms that two 16 year old (in another Haaretz account, 14 and 15 years old) minors from Isfiya have been detained under suspicion that they started the fires in the village dump.  But they aren’t charged with arson, rather with negligence.  This may have been a case of two young boys playing in a place they shouldn’t have, and perhaps having a match or finding something flammable and setting it alight as part of the mischief teenage boys do when they’re looking for kicks.  Was it dumb for kids to be playing with fire under such conditions?  You bet.  But doing something dumb is not the same as deliberately committing an act of terror.  That distinction seems to be lost on most Israeli Jews.

Further, the suspects’ father claims the boys are completely innocent, that the fire started far from their home, and that his children weren’t anywhere near the scene.  So it is possible that these boys are being framed by a government looking for patsies.

What is far more serious is that in a region facing the worst drought in the history of the State, when notified by an aircraft pilot of a small garbage fire that could’ve been extinguished by a garden hose, authorities engaged in far more severe negligence by not bringing fire equipment to the site until two and a half hours after the first report of the fire:

A flight instructor said yesterday he spotted the Carmel fire early and alerted the fire department, but the first plane sent to battle the blaze took off more than two hours later.

The instructor, Alon Chaim, noticed the fire near a rocky area on the outskirts of the Druze village of Isfiya during a flight lesson. Chaim said he reported the fire to the air traffic controllers at Haifa Airport, who in turn alerted the fire department at 11:14 A.M. Chaim filmed the fire while continuing with his lesson.

“I flew with a student. I saw smoke over the Carmel hills,” he said. “I flew over the fire, which at that point was a tiny blaze just outside Isfiya. It was very easy to get to it with a fire truck. I reported the fire to the air-traffic-control tower at Haifa Airport.”

Chaim said he had noticed the fire when it still could have been put out quickly.

The pilot said he later learned that the air traffic controllers first noticed firefighting aircraft in the region at 1:45 P.M.

That’s what caused this disaster: government negligence.  As the residents of Oakland who survived the devastating 1989 fire can tell you, a small fire left unattended becomes a monster given the right conditions.  In that incident, a fire crew extinguished the initial flames but did not do so completely and the fire reignited.  Death and heartache resulted from that mistake too.

Do you think the corrupt Interior Minister Eli Yishai, someone far more concerned with deporting children of foreign workers from Israel than fighting fires, will resign?  Think again.  His Shas Party is critical to the health of the current coalition government.  The Prime Minister can’t afford to jettison him.  So Yishai rises to his level of incompetence thanks to cronyism and backroom Likudist political deals.

In a nation run by responsible leaders mindful of their obligations to lead, such individuals would realize they must be extremely careful in their statements during such a traumatic event.  That they must not amplify rumors, foment hostility and mistrust with unfounded accusations.  But such a nation is not Israel.  Here the Interior Minister who is most culpable for the disaster tries to pin the blame on the weakest link in the social chain, the Israeli Druze community.  Reporters allow suffering victims to pin the blame where it doesn’t belong.  People look for scapegoats rather than pinning the blame where it really belongs.

On a related matter, the prime minister’s military attache, Gen. Yonatan Locker, Googled “biggest fire fighting supertanker in the world” to find the Arizona company which has the distinction of owning such a plane.  That’s how Israel leased it to fight the Carmel fire.  When you can use Google to fight Israel’s worst natural disaster, you know the guys at “Do No Evil” have got a good thing going.  Now, if General Locker could just use Google to end the Israeli-Arab conflict!

Israel’s Carmel Fire: Racism Rears Its Ugly Head Even in Tragedy

Saturday, December 4th, 2010
carmel fire bus

42 prison guards died when this bus was trapped in the flames (Jack Guez AFP/Getty)

The worst forest fires ever to have struck Israel are sweeping through the Carmel Mountains surrounding Haifa.  42 prison guard trainees died when their bus was blocked on a highway and burned, thus cutting off their escape.  It is the worst loss of life in a natural disaster in Israel’s history.  17,000 have been evacuated.  The University is threatened.

While it is natural for human beings facing such tragedy to look for villains and scapegoats, it’s unfortunate the direction that attention has turned.   Israeli Jews have gravitated to a nasty spate of rumors blaming Palestinian Israelis for deliberately setting the fires as an act of terror and protest.  This commenter in a comment thread here writes, linking to the Drudge-like Rotter internet news portal (and rumor-mill):

…According to Haifa radio today, Arab citizens in the town of Fureidis, were seen cheering the massive forrest [sic] fire occuring in the Carmel forrest [sic] that has taken the lives of at least 40

http://rotter.net/cgi-bin/forum/dcboard.cgi?az=read_count&om=18440&forum=scoops1

In fact, this Arab news source says that on Saturday, the residents of the town actually gathered in the soccer stadium to pray for rain.  Either the earlier rumor is wrong or Fureidis is massively schizoid.

Only a day earlier, the same individual wrote this:

…During wartime they’re [Israeli Palestinians] a security risk. Most Jewish Israelies [sic] believe that they’d join the enemy and try to join the war.

And a different commenter writes about the fires:

There are rumors of arson. The rumors blame the fires on Israeli Arabs, Heuzballa’s and even Iran’s agents…Reset Bet (Channel 2, the public news channel) – A wave of arson in the north, two suspects captured.

Rotter itself fuels the flames with this:

Shabak has been called into investigate the forest fires

Since the fires began spreading throughout the north, the national police have transferred the investigation to the Shabak.  Great concern that orders to set the fires originate in terror elements.

carmel fire

Air tanker fighting Carmel fire (Uriel Sinai/Getty Images)

Funny thing that this alleged report hasn’t been confirmed anywhere else in the Israeli media.  But now that it’s circulating in the Israel right-wing underworld of rumor and hate, the notion will have a long shelf life.  All this reinforces a right-wing nationalist narrative that proclaims that the Palestinian minority is the enemy within, a force that can never be trusted.  One that will side with “the enemy” during war or security crisis.

There’s only one problem with this line of thinking: it’s wrong.  Dead wrong.  Except for a few minor exceptions and despite massive levels of hate, mistrust and discrimination, Israeli Palestinians have shown remarkable dedication to the State, which is, after all, their country.

Let’s examine the reputable Israeli media reporting on the fires.  True, one strain of reporting emanating from the National Police (who tend to follow the Shabak’s lead and be harshly anti-Arab in their views and prejudices) arouses suspicion of arson.  But if you read the following carefully you’ll see that the police chief is not claiming the original fires were Arab-inspired arson, but rather that future copy cat fires might be.  Also, note how bereft of evidence or proof the police “suspicion” is in the first paragraph and that the police don’t even seem to be basing these suspicions on field investigations:

Close to a dozen fires broke out across the Galilee in northern Israel on Friday, even as fire fighters from Israel and abroad fought to contain a massive wildfire which has swept across a huge swathe of the nearby Carmel region. Police suspect that the new blazes were set deliberately.

Police Commissioner David Cohen earlier Friday warned local police chiefs to prepare for a spate of fires that had been purposely started. Police fear that some would take advantage of the current crisis to start more fires in the region.

Further fueling the rumors were reports that two residents of a Druze village were arrested on suspicion of setting the fires.  But the suspects were quickly released:

Two male residents of Daliat al-Carmel were released on Friday after having earlier been arrested on the suspicion that they had attempted to ignite fires in the Carmel hills region.

After being questioned by police, it became clear that the two were not responsible for the acts they were suspected of.

The second strain of reporting seems to derive from fire department sources who are on the scene or in contact with those who are.  This strain rejects claims of arson completely:

The initial inquiry conducted by fire investigators has pointed to negligence, not arson, as the cause of the wildfire.

According to the investigation, the wildfire started at one location west of Ussifiya. It is believed that household trash and tires that had been discarded in the area caught on fire and the fire spread. Investigators are looking into what exactly caused the trash to ignite.

While it’s too early to know definitively what the final determination will be, I feel safe saying that it’s likely that Israeli racism fueled by great pain and suffering has induced Jews to level yet another form of blood libel against their fellow Palestinian citizens.

The wild exaggeration hasn’t been limited to blaming Israeli Palestinians either.  Ynetnews blares this headline:

Hezbollah Overjoyed by Fire

The body of the report says no such thing.  It quotes the following Hezbollah statement:

The great Carmel fire embarrassed Israel’s firefighting capabilities and proved its almost complete incompetence,” a report by Hezbollah’s al-Manar network said. The Lebanese station said the poor performance came despite Israeli claims regarding the IDF Home Front’s full readiness to cope with any emergency and face the implications of an all-out war.

Even most Israelis would agree with these sentiments.  So where’s the joy?

I might add that among the 42 Israelis who died during the fires were three Druze and one Ethiopian.  Instead of falling prey to ethnic division and scapegoating, why can’t Israelis focus on the fact they all (Jewish and Palestinian) have lost something deep and painful with this natural disaster?  Why not acknowledge that the PA sent its firefighters to battle the blaze and Turkey too offered help?  Instead of finger-pointing at the weakest link in society and blaming them, why don’t Israelis turn their wrath where it belongs–toward an inept government more attuned to building expensive high-tech walls, Iron Dome anti-missile defenses, and buying F-35 jets as toys for the IAF; when it could’ve bought or leased a single air tanker that could’ve attacked this fire when it was at its origins, instead of having to wait for nations like Cyprus and Greece to send their equipment after the conflagration went out of control.

I write this post in the context of a disturbing survey by the Israel Democracy Institute baring the deep racism inherent in Israel society toward the Palestinian minority.  In the ways in which Israeli Jews have contemplated this disaster, the bad news of this poll have been borne out.

UPDATE: An up to the minute report from an Israeli reader confirms that the police are now agreeing that the fire was caused by negligence.  What are the odds that any Israeli politician or police officer will ever apologize to Palestinian citizens for promoting these rumors?

Assange’s Delusions on Bibi and Mideast Peace, Amazon’s Spinelessness

Friday, December 3rd, 2010

The problem with writing a blog is that you write one thing one day and by the next it’s overtaken by events and you have to backtrack and take back almost everything you said the day before.  Such is the case with Julian Assange, about whom I wrote that it would be enormous folly for the U.S. to prosecute him for espionage violations for his role in the Wikileaks episode.

While I stand by what I wrote regarding this, I have to add that Julian Assange is coming across more and more as a semi-delusional personality.  As Roger Cohen writes in today’s NY Times, the guy knows next to nothing about the Middle East or Israeli politics.  You can see that from the nonsense he spouted in a Time Magazine interview in which he said:

…We can see the Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu coming out with a very interesting statement that leaders should speak in public like they do in private whenever they can. He believes that the result of this publication, which makes the sentiments of many privately held beliefs public, are promising a pretty good [indecipherable] will lead to some kind of increase in the peace process in the Middle East and particularly in relation to Iran. I just noticed today Iran has agreed to nuclear talks. Maybe that’s coincidence or maybe it’s coming out of this process, but it’s certainly not being canceled by this process.

There are so many things wrong with this it’s hard to know where to start.  First, Bibi Netanyahu should talk about saying the same thing in private that he says in public.  The problem with Israeli policy is that it says one thing in private and does the exact opposite (or pretty much whatever it wants) in public.  Take Meir Dagan’s promise to Bush’s national security advisor that Israel didn’t intend to attack Syria, made only two months before Israel took out an alleged nuclear reactor there.

Second, and as Cohen noted, Bibi is talking about Israel’s desire for war against Iran.  He wishes foreign leaders would back up their hostile words spoken privately to U.S. ears with public hostility toward Iran.  This would bring the Middle East closer to war, not peace.  So if you think a U.S. or Israeli attack on Iran will lead to some kind of “increase” in the peace process then you’re with Julian on this one (and belong in the loony bin).  But if you’re someone who has his head screwed on right, both Bibi and Julian are full of s(&t on this one.

Which all goes to show you that even people who are doing the right thing may be doing it for the wrong reasons.  Or may have feet of clay.  Whistleblowers like Assange often have very complicated, and sometimes personal, or not very noble reasons for their actions.  At times, they don’t understand the magnitude of their actions and their long-term impact on themselves, their loved ones or their audience.  I know this from my own interaction with such a source.

joe lieberman

Joe 'I-Brought-Down-Wikileaks' Lieberman, tin-pot senator

On a related note, Amazon has caved in spectacular fashion to Joe “Little Mussolini” Lieberman by yanking Wikileaks off the Amazon servers for supposed violation of terms of use.  So much for web hosts upholding freedom of speech and the free exchange of information on the internet.  What shocks me is Amazon’s explanation for its actions:

Amazon…said that it had canceled its relationship with WikiLeaks not because of “a government inquiry,” but because it decided that the organization was violating the terms of service for the program.

“When companies or people go about securing and storing large quantities of data that isn’t rightfully theirs, and publishing this data without ensuring it won’t injure others, it’s a violation of our terms of service, and folks need to go operate elsewhere,” the company said.

Talk about speaking truthfully in public settings, Amazon is lying and doing so unconvincingly.  Of course they dumped Wikileaks because of a government inquiry and government pressure.  Of course they didn’t want to be on the wrong side of a Washington power-broker who could cause them no end of headaches.  What do you think that phone call from Joe Lieberman was?  An invitation to the dance?

We got mad at Google and Yahoo for acquiescing to Chinese censorship.  This isn’t that much different.  Someone in the government who can make your company’s life a living hell tells you to get rid of Wikileaks and instead of considering your options or corporate reputation if you cave, you promptly follow orders and dump ‘em.

Amazon’s finding that Wikileaks doesn’t “own” the data or that is isn’t rightfully theirs is just plain wild.  On what basis are they saying the material isn’t rightfully theirs?  Isn’t that for a court to decide?  And what violation of law specifically has Wikileaks engaged in in receiving or storing the documents?  That hasn’t been proven either.  Yes, one could argue that Bradley Manning, the actual leaker violated military guidelines.  But Wikileaks?  That’s hard to tell without legal adjudication.

Besides, if Wikileaks violated Amazon’s terms of service by uploading this material to its server doesn’t every newspaper website which is featuring the same material risk violating the terms of service of their web hosts?  Should the NY Times’ webhost take down its site for this reason?  Where do you draw the line?

At any rate, the bottom line is that Amazon is a spineless wimp which ought to recall the corporate slogan of another online corporate behemoth, Google: Do no evil.  Amazon, you’ve done bad today.  Very bad.  I hope you get so much nasty negative publicity from this that you live to regret your spinelessness.  At the first sign of trouble, you head for the hills.  Is this any way to stand up for free speech on the web?  To support those who speak truth to power?

There’s a chance Julian Assange may be Time’s Person of the Year (note: I didn’t vote for him).  I hope if he is he takes a nice big pot shot at Amazon for caving to U.S. government bullies.

One-Third of Israeli Support Wartime Concentration Camps for Palestinian Citizens

Thursday, December 2nd, 2010
japanese internment camp

Fate of Israeli Palestinian children during next war or crisis?

One nugget I overlooked (pg. 142) in the Israel Democracy Institute annual survey which I featured here a day or so ago is this one that Ofer Neiman pointed out to me.  33% of Israelis support placing Israeli Palestinian citizens in concentration camps during wartime.  Only 50% of Israeli Jews oppose this approach.  The actual presentation of the result in the full survey pulls punches I think, or perhaps the writers are so innured to Israeli racism they believe that the fact that half the Jewish population opposes sending their fellow citizens to Manzanar is something positive:

…The prevailing view among the Jewish public (50%) is that Israel should not follow in the footsteps of the United States (which during World War II placed its Japanese citizens in internment camps for fear that they would assist the enemy) and detain Arab citizens in the event of war or a grave security crisis.  One third (33%), however, actually favor such a step in wartime…

I try not to be surprised by anything when it comes to issues like this of Israeli racism, but the shock of this one is hard to avoid.

U.S. Contemplates Criminal Charges Against Wikileaks Founder

Thursday, December 2nd, 2010

I’d hoped that with the demise of the Bush administration we would leave the realm of Really Bad Ideas like the Patriot Act, Guantanamo, criminalizing free speech and being Muslim, etc.  Yes, I know that the Obama presidency has a pretty sordid record of maintaining some of the worst of these laws.  But until now, it hadn’t done much to add to the damage by creating new Really Bad Ideas.  Until this report in today’s NY Times, saying the government was contemplating charging Julian Assange with some form of espionage for releasing the hundreds of thousands of U.S. diplomatic cables which have so embarrassed our government.

I admit that if I were a senior government official, this development would be making me tear my hair out.  And I understand when human beings are deeply frustrated they contemplate doing really extreme things.  But not this, please not this.

Julian Assange may be a lot of things.  He may not be a pleasant person.  He may be self-righteous.  He may think he’s God’s gift to Man (and women).  But prosecuting him is a Really Bad Idea.  First, it will be almost impossible to win a conviction.  Second, it will turn him into even more of a martyr than he is now.  Third, it will turn the civil liberties community against Obama even more forcefully than it already is.  Fourth, it will motivate Wikileaks supporters and potential whistleblowers to dig even deeper and expose even more secrets.  This can only end badly for the government.

As to how difficult this prosecution would be: remember one of the last people charged under the 1917 espionage statute?  That would be Daniel Ellsberg.  That didn’t end so well for the government.  Nor did the prosecution of Steve Rosen and Keith Weissman under that same statute.

Whistleblowers like Assange, imperfect as they and their motivations may be, perform a benefit for society.  They cleanse the system.  They reveal secrets that often are better seen in the light of day.  These secrets allow us to understand our world better and be better citizens for it.  This is also true of Shammai Leibowitz, the Israeli-American who last spring began serving a federal prison sentence for leaking government secrets to a blogger.  Ellsberg invokes Shammai, Bradley Manning and Julian Assange as courageous souls for puncturing the shroud of government secrecy.  That sounds about right.

So Pres. Obama and AG Holder–don’t make this Really Big Mistake, if you know what’s good for you.

Israel’s ‘Organized Crime’: Mafia and Mossad

Wednesday, December 1st, 2010
alperon hit

Alperon's car and body after bomb explosion

I’ve written here about as assassination and attempted assassination in Teheran a few days ago, which Haaretz’ Yossi Melman attributes to the Mossad.  In these cases, the two scientists were driving in their cars to work with their wives.  They’d pulled into the university parking lot when a motorscooter pulled alongside and the driver threw a magnetic bomb at the driver side window, pulled away and then detonated his device.  In one case, the victim was killed; in the second, he was seriously injured.

Compare this account to the following from a May 15, 2009 Wikileaks cable:

In November 2008…Yaakov Alperon was assassinated in broad daylight in a gruesome attack on the streets of xxxx, only about a mile away from the Embassy. According to several media accounts, a motor scooter pulled up alongside Alperon’s car and the rider attached a sophisticated explosive device with a remote detonator to the car door. The bomb killed Alperon and his driver, and injured two innocent pedestrians. The hit was the latest in a series of violent attacks and reprisals, and indicated a widening…war…

What’s the difference?  In the first case, criminality was used to pursue state policy.  In the second case, criminality was used in pursuit of the ends of Israeli organized crime.  In fact, the U.S. embassy cable includes this telling statement:

…The old school of Israel OC [organized crime] is giving way to a new, more violent, breed of crime…The new style of crime features knowledge of hi-tech explosives acquired from service in the Israeli Defense Forces…

This invokes one of the most profound insights of the film, M, that is, that the forces of the state and laws that govern them are sometimes no different than those of the criminals they pursue.  Where do we think Israeli criminals learn their “skills?”  In killing Palestinians of course while serving their nation.  These two passages prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that this experience is exploited for corrosive effect within Israeli society.  Bringing the Occupation back home with a vengeance.

The entire cable linked above is instructive reading in terms of educating one about the penetration of organized crime into many corners of Israeli life and world commerce.  One claim I find hard to believe is the following:

It is not entirely clear to what extent OC elements have penetrated the Israeli establishment and corrupted public officials. The INP [Israeli National Police] insists that such instances are rare, despite the occasional revelation of crooked police officers in the press.

In fact, the Israeli police are widely regarded by Israelis as corrupt, brutish and ineffective.  In some regard, it doesn’t matter whether organized crime has penetrated the ranks.  It might as well have considering how useless the cops are there.  Besides the tour de force blog post written by Eyal Clyne which documents scores of incidents of police mayhem as reported in the Israeli media, note that only 41% of Israelis have full or partial confidence in the police.  In a 2009 Gallup poll, 59% of Americans expressed full or partial confidence in their police.  Israeli is a country in which the rule of law is a concept but not a reality.  And a good part of the reason for this is the debilitating effect of the Occupation on every aspect of Israeli society.

Limits of Israeli Democracy

Wednesday, December 1st, 2010
death to arabs graffiti

'Death to Arabs' graffiti on Jaffa mosque (Haaretz)

The Israel Democracy Institute has published its 2010 Democracy Index (abstract and full report).  It is a particularly comprehensive document and therefore especially interesting.   As always with such surveys of Israeli opinion, its reveals a deeply ambivalent, conflicted and confused society regarding what should be the nature of the Israeli state.  Israelis want democracy because they realize they should.  But they don’t want it so much that they would embrace all the awkward, conflicting values that go along with it.  Israelis clearly are Islamophobic, misogynist, and homophobic.  Yet these tendencies don’t seem to trouble them overly much.  They believe that somehow they’re entitled to their prejudices due to Israel’s status as unwanted interloper in the Middle East.  When you’re done reading this summary you’ll no doubt scratch your head and say: just what do Israelis want?  Even they don’t know.  I’d say a country whose citizens don’t know what they want their state to be are in trouble.

The following is a summary of key indices:

Israel’s high incarceration rate, combined with inadequacies in the rule of law, cause it to fall short of the accepted standard in Western countries.

Israel’s gender equality indicators have declined…

In the Political Stability Index, Israel ranks last among the democracies studied.

Israel scores low marks in the area of social cleavages; these divisions affect the country’s democratic quality and are not diminishing with time.

Here are some of the salient poll numbers:

60% of the population in Israel thinks that a few strong leaders would be better for Israel than all the democratic debates and legislation.

86% of the Jewish public (76% of the total population) thinks that critical decisions for the state should be made by the Jewish majority.

53% of the Jewish public also believe that the State is entitled to encourage the emigration of Arabs [ed., transfer].

81% of the population agrees with the assertion that “democracy is not a perfect regime, but it is better than any other form of government.” However, 55% of the public believes that Israel should put observing the law and public order before the ideals of democracy.

On a scale of 1 to 10 with ten being the highest, the Jewish public awards Israel’s democracy an average grade of 5.4…and the average grade awarded to it by the Arab public (5.1) is slightly lower.

Only 41% of respondents said that they have full or partial confidence in the police force.

72% of the population say that they do not trust the political parties…

43% of the general population feels that it is equally important for Israel to be a Jewish and democratic country, while 31% regards the Jewish component as being more important, and only 20% defines the democratic element as being more important.

…39% believe that human rights are not sufficiently implemented.

54% of the Jewish public opposes the view that legislation should be passed penalizing anyone who speaks out against Zionism.

50% of the Jewish respondents agree that it is important to allow non-Zionist political parties to participate in elections.

56% of veteran Israelis agree that people who have refused to serve in the IDF should not be allowed to vote or stand in elections

51% of the general public approves of equality of rights between Jews and Arabs. The more Orthodox the group, the greater the opposition to equal rights between Jews and Arabs: only 33.5% of secular Jews oppose this, compared with 51% of traditional Jews, 65% of Orthodox Jews and 72% of ultra-Orthodox Jews.

51.5% of the Jewish sample agrees that only immigrants who are Jewish as defined by Halakha should be entitled to receive Israeli citizenship automatically…

55% of the general public thinks that more resources should be allocated to Jewish municipalities than to Arab municipalities…

Within the Jewish public, 71% of right-wing supporters agree that more resources should be allocated to Jewish municipalities than to Arab municipalities, as compared to 46% of centrists and 38% of leftists [!]

39% of the general population supports equal funding of religious services [ed., for all religious groups]

46% of the Jewish public admitted to being most bothered by the possibility of having Arabs as neighbors. This was followed equally by people with mental illness being treated in the community and foreign workers (39% each). 25% would be bothered by same-sex couples, 23% by ultra-Orthodox Jews, 17% by Ethiopian immigrants…

Here are a few of the results that jumped out at me as especially contradictory and/or troubling.  While a vast majority of Israelis supported democracy as the best, though imperfect system, a smaller majority support rule by strongmen.  Figure that one out!  A majority of Israelis supports the notion of transfer, though in this poll it was euphemistically referred to as “encouraging emigration” of Arabs.  A bare majority support equal rights for Jews and Arabs (better known as Palestinians!).    A bare majority would offer citizenship (through Right of Return) only to those considered Jewish under Orthodox halachic srtictures.  A healthy majority favors a lower funding level for Arab municipalities (which has in fact been de facto policy since the founding of the State).

A result that troubles me as much or more than any other is that over 1/3 of those considering themselves “leftist” hold the racist notion that Arab municipalities should receive less government funding than Jews.  In fact, these people are not leftist and have no right to consider themselves so.  What they are is PEP: progressive except [for] Palestinians.  But that’s not truly progressive.  It’s bastardized progressivism.

A sharply divided respondent pool believes by a bare plurality that religious services for Jews, Muslims and Christians should be funded equally.

Israeli racism ranks its prejudices in the following order of intensity: Arabs, mentally ill and foreign workers, gays, and Ethiopians.  To be fair, Palestinian citizens also show prejudice but mainly against gays.

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE