Mahzor

New York Public Library

Churches

Sarajevo Haggadah

Mah Nishtanah

Sarajevo haggadah

Antaea Darom

Israeli women's art

Action

Torah as music

Ben Heine

Action

ceramic bowl

Mohammad Said Kalash, "Offering Reconciliation" exhibit (photo: Ilan Amihai)

Action

Punch and Judy/Pinchas and Jamila

Avi Katz

Action

David Grossman

Ben Heine

Action

Eldrige Street shul

Lower East Side

Action

Dove

Ben Heine

Action

Two birds

Hoda Jamal

Action

Israeli and Palestinian boys

from documentary, Promises

Action

Cat in the Hat

Yiddish version

Action

Daylight through the Wall

Banksy: graffiti art on Separation Wall

Action

Maurice Sendak's Brundibar set

New Victory Theater (photo: Nan Melville/NYT)

Action

Daniel Barenboim, West-Eastern Divan Orchestra

Palestinian-Israeli musical ensemble (photo: Kerstin Joensson/AP)

Action

Great Day on Eldrige Street

N.Y.'s klezmer greats celebrate shul rededication (photo: Leo Sorel)

Action

Joint Appeal for Peace

(Avi Katz)

Joint Appeal for Peace

Ketubah, Ancona, Italy (1772)

(Jewish Theological Seminary library)

Ancona ketubah

Archive for August, 2010

Is Joseph Moshe Mr. X?

Tuesday, August 17th, 2010

What do a high speed L.A. car chase, a deadly fungus, a man who may or may not be a Mossad biological weapons scientist, and an unknown Mr. X held incommunicado in an Israeli jail have in common?  Perhaps very little or a great deal: therein lies the tale.

In 2009, a man named Joseph Moshe, who claimed he was a former Mossad microbiologist who had done research on a deadly fungus at a California lab, allegedly threatened the president (though this account has been disputed).  While on his way to the Los Angeles Federal building, the police killed his engine with an electromagnetic pulse, smashed his windshield in and pumped three tear gas rounds and pepper spray into his car, none of which persuaded him to give up.

Finally, after being tasered he was subdued and arrested.  But before he could appear in court he was transferred to a state mental hospital.  From there he seems to have disappeared.  In a Huffington Post thread, a commenter claims Moshe was returned to Israel where he has not been heard from since.

A Truthout article from May, 2010 ties Moshe to a mysterious and virulent fungus epidemic which has killed at least 30 people in an outbreak in the Pacific Northwest that first surfaced in 1999:

…Researchers at Israel’s Institute for Biological Research, located in Ness-Ziona about 20 km from Tel Aviv, have worked with the Cryptococcus gatti fungus. They also report that mysterious Israeli-American scientist Joseph Moshe, 56 years old, may have conducted covert studies with the fungus while he was recently living in California. This report concerning Moshe is especially interesting because Moshe was briefly in the international spotlight in 2009 when he was the subject of a spectacular chase and arrest by the LA police department and SWAT team, assisted by the FBI, Secret Service, CIA, US Army and several other unidentified federal officials. That highly unusual arrest has never been fully explained to the media, and the whereabouts of Moshe has remained unknown since its occurrence.

…According to the Los Angeles media, which recorded the entire incident by helicopter and ground cameras, Moshe claimed to be “a former Mossad microbiologist” who had telephoned a police dispatch number before his pursuit and had made “threatening statements about the White House and the president.” Reportedly, Secret Service spokesman Ed Donovan confirmed this when he spoke with several Los Angeles reporters.

…Two former Fort Detrick biochemists, have also linked Moshe to a mysterious disease that is becoming alarmingly common in Vermont and other states, including California. The disease is known to have killed or incapacitated at least 10 to 20 rural dwellers and farmers. This disease is said to be Morgellons disease or “a rare, mutated form of Morgellons disease.”

Haaretz reported on this outbreak of the Cryptococcus gatti fungus as well and noted a possible tie-in between Moshe and the fungus.  Haaretz’s security analyst, Yossi Melman, wrote in more detail (Hebrew) about Moshe.  He notes a theory that Joseph was also attempting to blow the whistle on Baxter Pharmaceuticals, which was allegedly testing an H1N1 vaccine in Ukraine, then undergoing a severe Swine flu outbreak which resulted in 360 deaths.  Joseph, according to some accounts, claimed the vaccine was tainted and was attempting to make this known to U.S. authorities when he was apprehended.

Meanwhile, last June I wrote a post about a mysterious “Mr. X,” being held incommunicado in Ayalon Prison.  In an article that was subsequently removed by the Israeli censor, a reporter noted that the man’s identity was unknown even to his jailers, that he was not allowed any visitors, and that no one even knew what his crime was or whether he had indeed committed one.

A commenter in the post thread suggested that Mr. X was Joseph Moshe and linked to the Truthout article.  A Reddit link to a now defunct website, josephmoshe.org, also claims Moshe is Mr. X.  One wonders what happened to the website.

Even if you discount some or even most of the theories recounted above, the possibility that Joseph may be held as Mr. X in Ayalon Prison should be enough for Israeli journalists to ask the Israeli prison authorities whether they’re holding him or not.   Even if he’s not Mr. X, I think the Israeli public has a right to know who Mr. X really is and why he is being held incommunicado.  What has this man done to deserve the treatment he’s receiving?

If it turns out that Joseph IS Mr. X it will call to mind another case with certain similarites.  One of the most embarrassing espionage cases in Israeli history involved Dr. Marcus Klingberg, a senior biological weapons research scientist who also worked at the Ness Ziona lab mentioned in several of the articles linked above.  The Shin Bet suspected Klingberg of spying for the Soviet Union, disappeared him for 10 days during which he confessed to spying, and then sentenced him to a long prison term.  He wasn’t heard from again for the next ten years.  He completely vanished.  His family simply didn’t know what happened to him.  The State wouldn’t tell them or the nation anything.  After suffering several major strokes in prison, the State allowed him to leave prison and the country where he now lives in exile.

Unfortunately, Israel has a habit of disappearing inconvenient individuals who pose, not a danger to the state, but an embarrassment to it and its intelligence organs (it also did so to Anat Kamm for a time).  One wonders what embarrassment the case of Mr. X may be concealing.

Man May Propose and God Dispose, But in Israel the IDF Proposes and Disposes

Sunday, August 15th, 2010
barak before tirkel commission

The smug, self-satisfied smirk of a Defense Minister about to swallow the IDF canary

There is a saying that Man proposes and God disposes (in U.S. politics it’s “the President proposes, Congress disposes”).  But in Israel the IDF proposes AND disposes.  This is a process of which I have long been especially critical.  In most democracies the military echelon answers to the political echelon and the latter can exercise some control over the former.  Not in Israel.  In that country, the IDF has become such a sacrosanct institution that it rules the roost both in terms of developing and implementing military policy.  It even controls to a certain extent the political ramifications of that policy.

The effect is to make the army an entity that is accountable to no one.  Which in turn, causes the momumental blunders and self-deceving strategic decisions it has made in recent years including the Lebanon and Gaza wars and the Mavi Marmara fiasco.

Reuven Pedatzur, one of Israel’s leading academic experts on military strategic policy, has written a powerful account of this problem in Haaretz.  It’s a primer for the study of the IDF’s overweening pride and the willingness of the political elites to defer to the army.  He especially notes how both Bibi Netanyahu and Ehud Barak not only blamed the IDF for the failure of the Gaza flotilla operation, they also confirmed that as political leaders they relied on the IDF, and not their own analyses or judgement, to determine whether an operation could succeed and should be pursued.  Can anyone think of a worse way of running a supposedly democratic country?

The army chief of staff has announced to the world during his testimony to the Tirkel Commission that the IDF in future, when it attempts to stop boats seeking to run the Gaza blockade, will position snipers to kill unruly passengers.  This is a formula for even more deadly massacres than the last one.  Of course, no one in the political leadership will question this decision.  It will be accepted as are virtually all IDF judgments.

U.S. Claims PA to Return to Direct Negotiations, Quartet to Reaffirm 1967 Borders, Israel Oblivious

Sunday, August 15th, 2010

If the Haaretz headline is right (which I by no means concede) and the U.S. claim that the PA is about to return to direct peace negotiations, and that the Quartet will issue a statement saying that 1967 borders are the basis for such a negotiation–are all correct…then how does that square with Israel’s virtual denial of the upcoming Quartet statement:

“Israel is not willing to agree to any preconditions from the back door via a Quartet announcement that will serve as a basis for the negotiations,” a senior official in Jerusalem said.

If you add to this Bibi Netanyahu’s recent explicit denial that 1967 borders are an acceptable precondition for Israel as covered here, how is there any basis to conduct this negotiation?  How can it succeed?  How can it end in anything but failure?  Do Barack Obama and George Mitchell know something we don’t know??

Israel Continues Effort to Turn MK Zoabi into Terrorist

Saturday, August 14th, 2010
haneen zoabi incitement

Profile Image for Israeli Facebook group calling for killing Zoabi

Readers of this blog will recall a post I wrote after the Mavi Marmara massacre in which Israeli Palestinian MK Haneen Zoabi was physically assaulted as she attempted unsuccessfully to address the Knesset on her return from her participation in the flotilla.  Subsequent to that, the Knesset further punished Zoabi by removing rights and benefits accorded to all members.

Now the military intelligence goons have released new, heavily edited video footage (video buffer is very slow) that makes the ridiculous claim that because she is seen walking down a common passageway on the ship on which other passengers are seen holding poles (with which they presumably, in the Israeli version, attacked IDF soldiers, though it doesn’t show them doing this) that she is a liar, fraud and terrorist.  In a second scene she is seen mounting a stairway in which men at least one floor above her are seen carrying poles.  At no point in the video does she see these allegedly armed figures, not does she interact with them.  In fact, there isn’t a single scene in the video in which she is in the same frame with the pole-bearers.

What does all this claim?  The astoundingly incriminating fact that an Israeli Palestinian Knesset member shared a ship among 600 other passengers in which she was in some indeterminate physical proximity to other passengers who were carrying poles.  Wow.  If that isn’t the smoking gun that Israel needs to bury this woman I don’t know what is.

The breathless prose of Haaretz’s reporter Jonathan Lis is indeed disgusting in that it plays into the smear mentality that has beset Zoabi since she returned from the flotilla.  He all but claims that she lied about not knowing there were armed men on the boat.  Indeed, why does it matter at all whether she knew or not?  Should she have clairvoyantly been able to foresee that passengers might attack the IDF soldiers assaulting the ship?  After she did know about the violence, should she have magically teleported herself off the ship?  Should she have stayed in her cabin cowering in a corner until the worst was over?  No,  you can’t win with these people.  They simply want their pound of Arab flesh and will take it any way they can.

Why do they hate her so?  Because she is young, charismatic, energetic, photogenic, fluent in Hebrew and a powerful representative for her people.  The Israeli right hates that.  It cannot abide having a capable opponent pointing out its flaws.  For this, it will silence her at the first opportunity.  This is video is yet another part of that assault.

What is most disturbing is the right-wing extremist reaction to this video.  One far right Knesset member calls it “incontrovertible proof that she participated in terror against Israel.”  Another calls upon Israel’s “Arab leadership” to end Zoabi’s career in the Knesset.  A member of Lieberman’s Yisrael Beitenu declares the footage proof that Zoabi belongs in the “Hamas government and not the Israeli Knesset.”

Frankly, I’m astonished that the Israeli propaganda machine is still crankin’ out this stuff this many months after the disaster.  It proves that Mavi Marmara continues to wound this government deeply.  Any Israeli seen to have aided in this effort will be targeted for severe punishment.

What is it like to be a Palestinian citizen of Israel?  Let Haneen Zoabi or any number of other Palestinian MKs tell you, who are subject to this sort of abominable treatment routinely from a racist, extremist, anti-democratic Jewish majority.

And will the Jewish “liberal” minority come to her aid?  Are you kidding?  Well, maybe they’ll say a word or two in her support as a fellow Knesset member.  Maybe they’ll oppose stripping her of her privileges.  Other than that, very little.

Mossad’s Brodsky Too Hot for Germany to Handle

Friday, August 13th, 2010

Germany decided that helping solve the al-Mabouh assassination was one potato that was too hot to handle when it released Mossad spy “Uri Brodsky” on bail and told him he could leave Germany immediately for Israel.  The German ‘cave’ is breathtaking in its abjectness.  I presume that Angela Merkel thinks she already has enough irons in the fire regarding the complexity of the EU-German relationship with Israel, that she wanted nothing to do with further complications like imprisoning a Mossad killer and getting to the bottom of the most breathtaking and doltish international assassination in recent years.  It could also have something to do with German war guilt and an unwillingness to hear Bibi play that Holocaust card yet again against it.

The Germans noted that if Brodsky refused to return to Germany for further hearings in his trial he would be subject to arrest for the original charges of espionage related to fraudulent efforts to secure a passport for one of the Dubai hitmen.  If he is captured in a third country with an extradition treaty he could be returned to Germany for trial.  But does any German in their right mind think that Uri Brodsky will go anywhere near Germany for the rest of his life?  He won’t return for his trial and he won’t return after that.  The Mossad will keep him well under wraps in that regard.  If he serves the spymasters again it will be in a country with no German extradition treaty.

And so one of the best and most likely ways of penetrating the veil of the al-Mabouh hit will be lost.  All because the Germans have no guts to force the Mossad to be accountable for its actions; and have no guts about forcing Israel to honor international law and national sovereignty.  But hey, Merkel will have gained the undying gratitude of Israel’s spookery and Bibi Netanyahu.  That counts for something, right??

I’ve written here in the past that “Uri Brodsky” is not this man’s real name.  He stole that identity too from an actual Israeli named Uri Brodetzki, who is a student in San Francisco, and whose parents are outraged that their spy agency put their son’s life in danger by implicating him in anti-Palestinian terror.

The Race for Ramat-Kal: It Ain’t Over Till the Fat General Sings (and He Did, But It Still Ain’t Over))

Friday, August 13th, 2010
galant memo

Partial image of purported Galant memo

Every four years or so there is an amazing beauty contest that goes on inside Israel to determine who will be the next IDF chief of staff (Ramat-Kal in Hebrew).  It’s a cross between a U.S. presidential race and the naming of a new pope.  There’s no white smoke coming out of a chimney at the Kirya (army headquarters).  But there might just as well be.

The reason for all the hoopla is that the IDF plays a role within Israeli society all out of proportion to the militaries of most other countries.  It is the glue that holds that society together since so many serve and the military plays such a critical role in the lives of those who serve within it.

This year there is another “race” for Ramat-Kal and the two main candidates seem to be Maj. Gen. Yoav Galant, of the Southern Command (which includes Gaza) and Deputy Chief of Staff Maj. Gen. Benny Gantz, .  The beauty contest hadn’t stirred up greater than normal interest until someone threw a live rat into the dressing room of the various beauty queen contestants vying for the title.  The “rat” in question was a leaked memo purporting to be written by a prominent Israeli PR firm.  The memo was a sort of opposition research document written on behalf of Galant and urging him to make public embarrassing information about Gantz that would torpedo his chances of getting the job.

Most Israelis probably know and even accept that there is backroom politicking that goes into the campaign to become chief of staff.  That wouldn’t surprise them at all.  But the idea that one candidate for the job would turn it into the type of sleazy mudslinging affair that many voters here in the U.S. have become used to in election campaigns is disturbing to Israelis.  They prefer to retain the illusion that candidates are vetted and promoted based solely on merit rather than connections.  This despite the fact that Israel invented the word (well, perhaps it has Russian origins, but Israel might just as well have invented it) proteksia. Add to all these operatic goings-on the fact that the PR consultant whose firm’s logo is displayed on the memo claims the memo is a fraud and that it was forged.  This could turn the creation of the document and its leaking into a crime.  And now you’ve got high drama, scandal, and everything that makes for a great summer soap opera.

If the memo was forged (and I’m not prepared to accept that it was), then the person who leaked it had a motive to harm Galant in his campaign to be named chief of staff. Galant himself is screaming bloody murder and writing furious letters to his boss, the current chief of staff complaining of the evil cabal out to destroy him and his reputation.  Methinks the general doth protest too much.  But one thing you’ve got to say, the level of histrionics does fit right in with our operatic theme.

avi bnayahu

IDF's Scheming, Leaking Fatboy Slim, Avi Bnayahu

So who leaked the memo?  There are hints and intimations all over the media and online forums.  But speculation centers on the current chief military spokesman, Brig. Gen. Avi Bnayahu, who is known as an especially slippery, scheming fellow (Hebrew),  about whom I’ve written here.  The question is: was Bnayahu attempting to hurt Galant’s candidacy and if so, why?  Israeli journalist Yoav Yitzhak believes that one motive may be to tarnish Defense Minister Barak, who was seen to be leaning toward appointing Galant.  If Bnayahu could make it appear that Galant was using improper smear tactics in his campaign, this could cause the latter’s candidacy to implode and by extension harm one of his champions, the Defense Minister, who would be made to look foolish for supporting such a Yahoo.

Further, the current chief of staff, Gabi Ashkenazi and Defense Minister Ehud Barak have had a falling out and the latter eased the former out of his job.  Ashkenazi would like to have some influence over the choice of his successor and the memo seemed designed to remove any leverage he might have by giving Galant a leg up over his competitor. Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein has now halted the naming of a new chief of staff until the legal issues can be sorted out.  In effect, he’s given Galant a time-out.

In case you can’t tell the players without a scorecard, let’s just put all the inside baseball aside and remember that Israel today stands at a crucial crossroads in terms of its relations with Lebanon, Syria and Iran.  It came close to a minor shooting war last week when an IDF Lt. Col. was killed by sniper fire and several Lebanese soldiers and a journalist were killed by Israeli return fire.  Despite the Syrian president’s repeated offers to negotiate with Israel over peace, Israel maintains a stolid “Nyet” that precludes talks and ratchets up tension between the two sides.  And finally, as Jeffrey Goldberg’s new Atlantic screed proves, there are Israelis in the political, military and intelligence echelons who have dreams of glory involving bombing Teheran and toppling the Ayatollahs.

What I want to know is how in hell is the IDF supposed to take on all these critical responsibilities to protect Israeli security when their generals seem more like the gang that couldn’t shoot straight??  Yediot a few days ago revealed yet another riveting internal IDF drama it called the “war of the generals.”  It involved the commander of the recent IDF military exercise which simulated a war on Israel’s norther border (hint, hint).  Apparently, early on the morning on which the maneuvers were to begin, Brig, Gen. Galant and his staff arrived unannounced at the command center for the exercise.  The commander, Yishai Bar, became furious and threatened to cancel the entire exercise unless Galant left (Bar had once been Galant’s assistant and there was bad blood between them).  Bar’s commanding officer refused to intervene and the exercise somehow went forward. Can you imagine major affairs of state subject to the petty jealousies and rivalries of the general staff?

I think all of this proves that the IDF is no longer the invincible war machine it once appeared to be lo these many years ago.  It has instead been transformed into an army of Occupation commanded by generals who treat their personal stock portfolios as more important than commanding troops in the field; and by generals for whom personal advancement has long ago replaced any devotion to nation or principle.  Woe unto a nation that relies on such mediocrity to defend itself from harm.  But really, is the army to blame for such fiascos?  Or is it the nation whose political leadership refuses to make the tough decisions necessary to guarantee the nation’s security for the coming generations?

Shin Bet Releases Accused Jewish Terrorist, Pearlman; What About Makhoul?

Thursday, August 12th, 2010

Today, the Shin Bet released accused murderer Chaim Pearlman from prison after a judge refused to extend his detention for an additional eight days.  Such refusal is quite unusual in a judicial system which grants utmost deference to security considerations.

Haaretz noted the news approvingly, as if this signified that Israeli democracy was working properly.  It did so while also rapping the Shin Bet over the knuckles for its sorry performance in rooting out Jewish terror and for abusing suspects (including Palestinians) in the process of investigating them.

In the final paragraph of the editorial, Haaretz made one interesting and important statement about the quality of evidence against the latest series of Palestinian Israeli security suspects; while making a glaring omission of important information:

Pearlman is not the only suspect in recent months who was arrested on the basis of serious allegations that quickly turned out to be false. He was preceded by several Israeli Arab detainees; in those cases, a raft of allegations produced little. Before the Shin Bet arrests people and makes false accusations, it should investigate carefully. It should remember that not everything is permitted in interrogations, and that torture – whether psychological or physical – is always unacceptable, no matter the case or the suspect. Even the war against terror must be conducted using legal means.

This is the first indication I have seen of media skepticism in the cases of Omar Said, Ameer Makhoul and the group I call the Syria 3, which includes long-time Shin Bet target, Mahmoud Masarwah.  I have been saying precisely the same thing for months myself.

The glaring omission is the fact that all these Arab suspects remain locked up indefinitely while Pearlman has gone free.  It should be noted that Pearlman is accused of multiple murders, which the Palestinian suspects are accused of spying.  Yet the former is free and the latter in prison.  This is justice in a democracy?

Netanyahu Rejects Return to 1967 Borders, Proximity Talks’ Latest Failure

Wednesday, August 11th, 2010

Israeli rightists and those echoing their formulations are fond of saying about the Palestinians: “There is no partner for peace.”  Well, now the Palestinians can legitimately say the same about the current Israeli government.  Haaretz today reveals that Bibi Netanyahu, in George Mitchell’s latest round of proximity talks, rejected a framework for direct negotiations that would have Israel affirm that 1967 borders would be the basis for such talks:

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu yesterday rejected a Palestinian demand that direct negotiations be based on a statement by the Quartet confirming its position that the future Palestinian state will be based on the 1967 borders.

Meeting in Jerusalem with U.S. envoy George Mitchell, Netanyahu repeated his demand for the renewal of direct talks without preconditions.

…Senior officials in Jerusalem who are involved in the efforts to renew direct peace talks said yesterday that Abbas’ latest formula was unacceptable to Netanyahu because it sought to impose preconditions that the Israeli public would oppose.

…After Netanyahu’s rejection, it appears that Mitchell’s latest visit to the region has ended in failure.

Affirming 1967 borders would be little more than a reformulation of every major peace proposal going back ten years from the Clinton and Taba talks to the Arab League proposal to the Quartet.  Bibi’s rejection sends Israel-Palestine relations into total disarray and renders Mitchell’s work moot.  And there certainly is now no Israeli partner.

It’s laughable that only 24 hours ago the N.Y. Times editorial board hectored Mahmoud Abbas about his refusal to enter into such talks with Israel.  The Grey Lady warned Abbas that Obama was the best president for the Palestinians’ purposes he was every likely to get, and that Obama’s patience would wear thin.  All empty threats and rhetoric.  The fact of the matter is that Israel’s position, as evidenced by Bibi’s “No” less than a day later, renders negotiations moot.  No serious Palestinian leader should or would be able to risk their position for the empty chalice offered by Israel and the U.S.  It would make them a laughingstock in the Palestinian street, and rightly so.

But let’s make no mistake: failure of peace talks does not bring a maintenance of the status quo as Bibi assumes.  It gives freedom of movement to all the gremlins who wish to work their mischief including radical settlers, Al Qaeda, radical Palestinian militant groups, Hezbollah, etc.  There are elements too within the IDF and Israeli political echelon who’d nothing more than a good war to occupy themselves and take the world’s eye off the Occupation and Palestinian suffering.  There are any rumblings above and below the surface that an imminent attack on Iran may be such a diversion.

So yes, there will be another war, and sooner rather than later.  And during that war or sometime after, Barack Obama and his advisors will scramble to try to pick up the pieces and get things back to status quo ante.  But that won’t work either since Obama is an incrementalist in a region where radical reform is needed to shake up people and nations who’ve been far too complacent for far too long.

So here’s my formula put in the most graphic terms possible: status quo=death.  Any person or party who maneuvers to maintain the status quo and stands in the way of progress as Bibi has done, will sow the seeds of despair and reap death as their harvest.

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE