Mahzor

New York Public Library

Churches

Sarajevo Haggadah

Mah Nishtanah

Sarajevo haggadah

Antaea Darom

Israeli women's art

Action

Torah as music

Ben Heine

Action

ceramic bowl

Mohammad Said Kalash, "Offering Reconciliation" exhibit (photo: Ilan Amihai)

Action

Punch and Judy/Pinchas and Jamila

Avi Katz

Action

David Grossman

Ben Heine

Action

Eldrige Street shul

Lower East Side

Action

Dove

Ben Heine

Action

Two birds

Hoda Jamal

Action

Israeli and Palestinian boys

from documentary, Promises

Action

Cat in the Hat

Yiddish version

Action

Daylight through the Wall

Banksy: graffiti art on Separation Wall

Action

Maurice Sendak's Brundibar set

New Victory Theater (photo: Nan Melville/NYT)

Action

Daniel Barenboim, West-Eastern Divan Orchestra

Palestinian-Israeli musical ensemble (photo: Kerstin Joensson/AP)

Action

Great Day on Eldrige Street

N.Y.'s klezmer greats celebrate shul rededication (photo: Leo Sorel)

Action

Joint Appeal for Peace

(Avi Katz)

Joint Appeal for Peace

Ketubah, Ancona, Italy (1772)

(Jewish Theological Seminary library)

Ancona ketubah

Archive for March, 2007

Masada2000 and ‘Neil Pomper’: Kahanists as Sore Losers

Wednesday, March 28th, 2007

A Kahanist allegedly named Neil Pomper was the first person to notify me that Masada2000 had a S.H.I.T. listing for me. This led, in turn to my notifyng the site’s host about its content. This in turn led to the site being taken down. After this, I wrote to Neil (if that’s his real name) suggesting that if he’d kept his big mouth shut, his site might still be beaming its hate all over the world.

Apparently, Neil hasn’t been able to get Masada2000 up again. But he’s resorted to the next best thing. Any slime bucket can create a blog at Blogger.com. So he’s impersonated me, and mimicked my name and created this defamatory blog which also infringes on copyrights of two images I own.

I am disappointed that Neil isn’t brave enough to turn on the blog’s comment features so I can send all of my readers there to tell him what a shit he is. It is also possible that “Neil Pomper” is either Rachel Neuwirth or a “good friend” of hers since I’ve tussled with her as well here making her none too happy.

At any rate, a claim of defamation and copyright infringement has been submitted to Blogger’s legal department and a DMCA notice will follow shortly. The site will be down in two shakes of a lamb’s tail. Hopefully, Blogger will monitor Neil’s fecal droppings better the next time he tries this sort of shenanigan. Some people have entirely too much time on their hands and manage to get themselves into tons of mischief.

If anyone’s an attorney or forensic computer sleuth and would like to help me pursue this individual, please contact me through this blog. And anyone who can use this internet header to help me get closer to identifying this jackass would be much appreciated:

Received: from web63108.mail.re1.yahoo.com ([69.147.97.3])
by rwcrmxc24.comcast.net (rwcrmxc24) with SMTP
id <20070329034513r2400bjmbce>; Thu, 29 Mar 2007 03:45:13 +0000
X-Originating-IP: [69.147.97.3]
Received: (qmail 42769 invoked by uid 60001); 29 Mar 2007 03:45:12 -0000
DomainKey-Signature: a=rsa-sha1; q=dns; c=nofws;
s=s1024; d=yahoo.com;
h=X-YMail-OSG:Received:Date:From:Subject:To:MIME-Version:Content-Type:Content-Transfer-Encoding:Message-ID;
b=mXTtQ3Iun+XCjYxAaAF/RVhNZg29mjCX+wbTFo4+56F6bFRjULEyBgFNDKuWaoNlckO90o2KoL/AWGtAqsndQGAK8hV/zzty62kI+WG0hZJlc7WAG0w91VVkGNy0ReXpN3NUHixUmKv2lNRmwjUQbzVTvRfg8PDbVIiN7u1uunI=;
X-YMail-OSG: 1hFKOWoVM1mMtCHMVm8OUwuBWQZ7mYzf452vDFXVUveATVLjR0MS5SUorNNEvWy.F.TZOzq5ASI66Vq74vmya.QKyA–
Received: from [69.109.63.194] by web63108.mail.re1.yahoo.com via HTTP; Wed, 28 Mar 2007 20:45:11 PDT
Date: Wed, 28 Mar 2007 20:45:11 -0700 (PDT)
From: Neil Pomper Subject: Hey, Creepy Dickie, do check the link enclosed, You Shmuck!
To:
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary=”0-121826942-1175139911=:40750″
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Message-ID: <955010.40750.qm@web63108.mail.re1.yahoo.com>“

Jewish and Israeli Blog Awards (JIBA) Revived

Tuesday, March 27th, 2007

Those of you who’ve followed this blog over the past two years may remember my crusade against the Jewish and Israeli Blog Awards (see the many posts I wrote) which were at the time run by Aussie Dave and sponsored by the Jerusalem Post. Among the criticisms I had were that Aussie Dave was running the competition as a committee of one which might allow personal whim or political prejudice to enter into his decision making. I also noted that Jerusalem Post’s sponsorship skewed the competition toward a heavily partisan political agenda represented by that Likud-oriented publication.

A new effort is underway in which a committee is running JIBA through a new blog called JBlogosphere (not to be confused with the Jewish blog aggregator Jblogosphere.com). The blog for JIBA says there are four sponsors but I haven’t seen who they are. There are also a few other heartening changes that indicate they may have taken some of my criticism to heart.

Two years ago all the categories and nominees were heavily skewed to the political right. As a result, Little Green Footballs and similarly oriented blogs won many of the categories. This year, there will be left, right and center blog categories which actually gives one of us an opportunity to compete on a somewhat level playing field. There were few progressive blogs nominated and only one or two won any awards in JIBA last time. So I was heartened by this posting at Jblogosphere:

“Perhaps we could bring in more left-wing bloggers on the “team” to make the teamwork a bit more diverse. After all, if we want to highlight Jblogs, promoting unity among Jblogs should be one of our absolute priorities.”

But will they promote unity by including progressive Jewish bloggers not only in competition but within the organizing committee?

Having “pro-Israel advocacy” categories as the organizers are proposing isn’t the best way of making us feel more included unless they can in good conscience include progressive Jewish blogs like mine within that rubric. I consider myself “pro-Israel” but I’m as much an advocate for Israeli-Palestinian peace as I’m an advocate for one side or the other in this conflict.

And in case the JIBA organizers are sincerely interested in being truly inclusive they should take a look at the Jewish/Israeli peace blogs featured at Israel-Palestine Blogs. All of those blogs should be encouraged to participate & included in the nomination process.

In short, I believe JIBA should do its best to be non-ideological in running this competition, voting, nomination & creating competition categories. They may not even realize it but JIBA was highly ideological & I worry that the upcoming competition will reproduce the worst offenses of that process.

This snarky comment leads me to question just how sincere the organizers may be about being truly inclusive of diverse political views:

“We’ve discussed the tension between being open to feedback and criticism from bloggers and the flame wars, which have erupted in the past because of a few individuals, who, um, offered less than constructive criticism. Well, trolls are just a part of life.”

Just like Robert Duvall’s character in Apocalypse Now who said: “Oh I do love the smell of napalm in the morning;” I do so love it when pro-Israel bloggers get so defensive that they have to accuse some of their fellow Jewish bloggers of being “trolls.” Since Aussie Dave and I engaged in some hot & heavy disagreements 2 years ago about his pseudo representative version of JIBA, I can only assume this passage refers to me.

They can flame me again if they choose to ignore my legitimate arguments. But this time I think they’ll be a few more of the progressive Jewish blogs watching what they’re doing and letting the rest of the blogosphere know if something’s not kosher in the land of blogs.

UPDATE: I received a personal e-mail from Chaim Rubin, who’s helping organize JIBA this year. Clearly, Chaim and I do not see eye to eye politically. But I was impressed that his reply lacked all the defensiveness and truculence of Aussie Dave’s replies to me during my contretemps with him 2 years ago. I know I’m probably going to disagree with some or perhaps even much of what happens at JIBA this year. But I’m convinced that in Chaim there is a person of good faith helping run the show. He’s offered to add me to the committee, which I didn’t think was a good idea since many of the substantive decisions have already been made regarding the competition. But I did think such an offer was a very good sign of openness to diverse points of view.

Tikun Olam Banned from JBlog Central

Tuesday, March 27th, 2007

In order to maximize exposure of this blog in the Jewish blogosphere, I’ve registered with a number of Jewish blog aggregators including Jblogosphere.com, JewishBlogging and Jrants. Each of them has been gracious enough to include my feed in their directory of Jewish blogs. I don’t get a huge amount of traffic from them but I get enough to find them a useful tool to disseminate my work and I appreciate the service they provide.

I also registered at a fourth aggregator, JBlogCentral, which is sponsored by IsraelForum. Oddly enough, I noted that after submitting my blog and seeing my posts display there they stopped appearing. So I submitted again and they resumed displaying on the site. And then they stopped again. When I searched the site for my posts using Google I could find them using Cache, but I got an error using the regular Google site link saying the page was no longer available.

When you’ve dealt with Jewish right-wingers as long as I have you can smell a rat a mile off and I sure smelled one. I did some research and discovered that IsraelForum is one of those right-wing pro-Israel sites. It tried to host a Jewish blogging award this year and got into such controversy with the original founder of the award that he withdrew approval for them to use the original name of the competition.

So I had a pretty good suspicion that I’d been blackballed for not being sufficiently “pro-Israel” enough for inclusion in the blog directory (the site does note in several places that it is “pro-Israel” by which they really mean they support a hard-right political agenda). Just for the hell of it, I thought I’d check the site rules to see which one I’d “violated.” Here’s all they say on the matter:

How do we decide which blogs to include in our service?
We have no particular policy, other than trying to avoid blogs that promote hate, illegal activities, adult content, etc. But we cannot guarantee that we will be 100% successful at our attempts to avoid such content. We rely on our readers to report content that is clearly inappropriate.

So either I “promote hate, illegal activities or adult content.” We can safely ditch the last item. I think we can safely ditch the second one as well. But “promoting hate”…not that’s an interesting one. Does a progressive Zionist blogger “promote hate” of Israel? Hmmm. Hard to wrap my mind around that one. And just what is it about my blog that merits exclusion from a site which purports in its name “JBlog Central” to be a central repository of Jewish blogging. Maybe they should change their name to “JBlog Not-So-Central?”

So what does that tell you about the ideological orientation of JBlogCentral and Israel Forum? I’ve written to the site each time I discovered my exclusion including most recently yesterday. Never got a response the first time. Let’s see what they have to say if anything this time.

And just in case they rewrite their rules to reflect my criticism, we’ll keep a copy of the cached page so we can remind them of the arbitrariness of their own rules.

Rashid Khalidi on Palestinian Unity Government

Monday, March 26th, 2007

Brit Tzedek hosted a conference call with Rashid Khalidi today that was most interesting. I was most impressed with how acute his thinking is on the conflict. This is the kind of person who could’ve been a prominent international lawyer or even foreign policy wonk if he’d chosen to be. Not the type of person who suffers fools gladly.

Khalidi revealed something that may be common knowledge to some familiar with U.S. Mideast policy but it was news to me. He claims that after Hamas came to power Eliot Abrams advocated a “hard coup” against the Hamas-led PA to be led by Mohammed Dahlan. Bringing Fatah back to power forcibly was to be the essence of U.S. policy toward the Palestinians, Khalidi derisively claimed.

Khalidi, in explaining why no Arab-American was invited to speak before a recent House committee discussing the Israeli Arab conflict, gave an interesting colloquy on Arab American political power. He likens the community to the Jewish community in the 1930s. He said that while there were many American Jews in 1930s America and that their leaders appeared to hold a certain level of status, in reality American Jews had very little power. Khalidi explained that Jews were ignored by FDR and other policy makers because they COULD ignore them and get away with it. As future generations of Jews became more educated about their rights and savvy about wielding political power, this could no longer happen.

Arab-Americans, who are largely first-generation, are in such a position right now. That is why a House committee chair could deign to hold a hearing on the I-P conflict and ignore the existence of the Arab side. But this will not be the case once Arabs become more savvy about wielding their political clout.

Khalidi feels that the Right of Return will be the thorniest problem to tackle between the two sides, even more difficult than Jerusalem and other territorial issues. The outline of what must happen to resolve this matter is that Israel will have to acknowledge the devasatation that the 1948 Nakba caused to Palestinian life. It won’t even have to apologize. But it will have to concede what happened. In kind, the Palestinians will have to give up their dreams of physically resettling their old homes within Israel proper. These will be two extremely difficult processes for both sides to come to terms with.

He noted that a certain number of Palestinian refugees should return to Israel and those should be the ones in Lebanon. They have never been absorbed into Lebanese society because of the political fracturing of that system. Many of these Palestinians origanally left northern Israeli Arab villages in the Gallilee which still exist. Khalidi’s argument is that these villages could easily reabsorb the refugees who return to them. He believes that Palestinian refugees in other places like Jordan, the U.S., Europe, etc. HAVE been reabsorbed into these societies and so it is far less imperative that they have a physical Right of Return.

By the way, if someone reading this knows Khalidi’s work better than I could you go to the Wikipedia article I link to above and edit it to read more neutrally. As it currently stands, two-thirds of the article details accursations by Khalidi’s critics with no rebuttal whatsoever. These two paragraphs should be entirely rewritten by someone with a more balanced perspective.

Passover Jewish Music on KBCS FM

Monday, March 26th, 2007

UPDATE: KBCS will rebroadcast this show this Sunday, April 20, 2008 at 7PM.  To listen live to the audio stream, click link in paragraph below.  A zis’n Peysach!

On Sunday, April 1st at 7 PM PDT, I’ll be hosting The Old Country, KBCS’ world music program. The theme will be Passover music since it will air the night before the first seder. Below, is the script I wrote for the show with links to most of the mp3 versions of the songs. Hope you can listen to the show and tell your friends to as well. KBCS is 91.3 FM and you can also listen live to the audio stream. You can also listen to the full hour show here.

A special thanks to Barbie-Danielle DeCarlo, producer of The Old Country for inviting me to do the show. If you like what you read or hear please consider buying a CD using the Amazon links I provide or making a donation to support my work through the Paypal link in my sidebar.

Introduction

Chag Sameach or Gut Yontof! That’s ‘Happy Holiday’ in Hebrew and Yiddish!

Passover or Pesach is one of the most important of the Jewish holidays. To my mind, it is among the most joyous of our celebrations. Other holidays are filled with mirth like Purim and Simchat Torah, but Passover is a festival of joy recollected in tranquility. It is the ultimate holiday of freedom marking the struggle of the enslaved Jews of Egypt to free themselves from bondage and found an independent nation in the Promised Land.

The festivals of the Jewish year revolve around an ancient agricultural calendar followed when Jews lived as farming tribes in the land of Israel. Passover, coming as it does in spring, was considered the New Year festival well before there was such a thing as Rosh Hashanah (which comes in the fall). Because of its association with spring, the holiday has always been connected to Song of Songs, the Biblical book of love, desire and devotion. We’ll be featuring the lyrics of Song of Songs in some of our music tonight.

“Passover” comes from the Hebrew word pasach to ‘pass over,’ which refers to the last of the ten plagues in which the Angel of Death “passed over” the homes of Jews which were smeared with the blood of the Paschal lamb sacrifice.

Passover is an eight day festival. On the first night we celebrate a seder (or ‘order’) by reading a book called the Haggadah (literally, “the telling”). The two most important elements of the seder are the Story and the Meal. The Haggadah is the Story. It recounts the Jews’ exodus from Egypt. It is filled with wise and wonderful sayings and prayers. A good number of them have been put to music. Music plays an important role in any good seder and we’ll be showcasing some of the most memorable songs here tonight. Finally, a seder concludes with a bountiful repast. Any gathering of Jews worthy of the name provides for a meal at which guests can commune, sing, gossip and worship together.

Music:

1. The traditional songs coming up were recorded by Yasmine, a group I co-founded with my brother in the 1980s. The suite includes Baruch HaMakom (“Blessed is the Place”– that is, God), Dayeinu, expressing gratitude to God for the wonderful gifts he bestowed on the Jewish people (“If He had only given us the Torah that would have been enough”), and Avadim Hayinu, a passage from the Passover Haggadah (“We were slaves in Egypt and now we are free”). We’ll be hearing Pesach Suite (hear it) from Yasmine.

Yasmine
Jewish Songs of Celebration & Struggle
Pesach Suite (4:41):
Baruch HaMakom
Dayeinu
Avadim Hayinu

Judeo Espanol sephardic greatest hits album cover
2. Next, we’ll hear from Yehoram Gaon, a golden-voiced Israeli popular singer who’s recorded several collections of music in Ladino. Ladino is a language that integrates Hebrew and Spanish and has been spoken by the Jews of the Mediterranean region (North Africa, Spain, Turkey, etc) for hundreds of years. I’ve included a good number of Sephardic tunes in this program because Seattle has the largest Sephardic Jewish community in the U.S. outside of Brooklyn. I’m featuring Gaon’s Un Cavritico (hear it).

Yehoram Gaon
Songs for Passover in the Sephardic Tradition
Sovre Una Cuanta Mas 1:23
Quen Supiense Y Entendiense 3:05
Un Cavritico 3:45
Shezufat Shemesh 2:24

the passover story album cover
3. The vocal sextet, The Western Wind, recorded this version of the beloved seder tune, Chad Gadyo (hear it), on their recording, The Passover Story:

Then came the Holy One, blessed be He, and slew the angel of death that killed the butcher that slaughtered the ox that drank the water that quenched the fire, that burned the stick that beat the dog that bit the cat that ate the goat my father bought for two zuzim, Had Gadya (one goat)…

Chad Gadyo is a song in form much like The House That Jack Built or The Twelve Days of Christmas. It is first recorded in a Prague Haggadah from 1590. This version was composed by the famous Yiddish theater composer, Moishe Oysher

The Western Wind
The Passover Story
Chad Gadyo (4:18)
Western Wind Records


4. This 1950 recording of the Yiddish Swingtette is not terribly Yiddish or Jewish (except for the melody derived from the seder tune, Dayenu (hear it). But it shows how a traditional Jewish liturgical song can be refracted through a jazz idiom.

Dave Tarras
Yiddish-American Klezmer Music 1925-1956
Dayeynu (1:42)
Yazoo Records

liturgy of ezra bessaroth album cover
5. Many listeners may know that Seattle has a large Sephardic community of 5,000 Jews. It’s reported to be the second largest in the country. There are two main synagogues serving the Sephardim. The emeritus cantor of Ezra Bessaroth, one of the two synagogues, Hazzan Issac Azoze, has a 2-CD set devoted to the liturgy of the congregation. He’s graciously provided me this mp3 file for tonight’s broadcast. It is the Ma Nishtanah (hear it) or Four Questions sung in the style of the Jews of Rhodes.

The Four Questions are usually sung by the youngest guest attending the seder. They are meant to teach children the basic rituals observed during the seder by comparing what we do at a normal meal and what we do at a seder:

“Why is it that on all other nights during the year we eat either bread or matzoh, but on this night we eat only matzoh?”
“Why is it that on all other nights we eat all kinds of herbs, but on this night we eat only bitter herbs?”
“Why is it that on all other nights we do not dip our herbs even once, but on this night we dip them twice?”
“Why is it that on all other nights we eat either sitting or reclining, but on this night we recline?”

Information about ordering the CD can be found at http://www.issacazoze.com/

Hazzan Issac Azoze
Liturgy of Ezra Bessaroth
Ma Nishtanah (1:49)

6. On Passover eve, April 19, 1943, German troops moved into the Warsaw ghetto to begin the final liquidation of the remaining ghetto inhabitants. They were met with fierce resistance by 750 Jews who decided to fight to the death rather than submit to the yoke of the tyrant. Max Helfman wrote Di Naye Hagode (“The New Haggadah”) as a requiem for the resistance fighters. It is meant as a “telling” of the tale of the uprising and as a lesson in the modern Jewish struggle for freedom.

It was one of Helfman’s signature compositions, based on a long poem written by the martyred Soviet Jewish poet (murdered by orders of Stalin), Itzik Feffer. Feffer and Helfman seize on the similarities between the plight of the Jewish slaves in Egypt and that of the doomed Jews of the Warsaw ghetto. Just as the former managed to liberate themselves from captivity, both poem and song envision the tragedy of the uprising leading to the overthrow of the cruel Nazi oppressor. I feature here Ma Nishtano (hear it) from Helfman’s composition.

Max Helfman
Di Naye Hagode
Ma Nishtano 5:06

Songs of Our Fathers
7. Adir Hu (hear it) is traditionally sung as part of the Hallel prayer at the conclusion of the seder:

Mighty is He,
May He soon build His House,
Speedily, speedily in our days.

It anticipates the rebuilding of the Holy Temple and the return of the Jewish people to the land of Israel.

This melody comes from the remarkable Hasidic musician and rebbe, Shlomo Carlebach. He was to Jewish music what Pete Seeger was to folk music: a fertile and fervent purveyor of spiritual Hasidism through music.

Andy Statman & David Grisman
Songs of Our Fathers
Adir Hu/Moshe Emes 4:14

Chants-Mystiques; Hidden Treasures Of A Living Tradition
8. In this recording of the seder song, Ki Lo No’e (hear it), we hear the remarkable Sephardic cantor Hazzan Alberto Mizrahi sing a version of another song written by the great Eastern European Jewish composer for Yiddish films, theater and synagogue, Moishe Oysher. While Oysher’s musical heritage derives from the Ashkenazim, Mizrahi makes a Jewish cross-cultural point by embracing this Ashkenazi rendition of the song.

Alberto Mizrahi
Chants Mystiques: Hidden Treasures of a Living Tradition
Ki Lo No’e (4:14)

Alain Scetbon's 'Haggadah de pessah'--buy it
9. Alain Scetbon’s Haggadah de Pessah is a recording of a traditional Tunisian seder. There are no liner notes accompanying the CD. The album narration is in French and pretty sparse and there’s no narration to Ya Ilana-Rabbi Nessim.
I surmise that Rabbi Nessim was a leading rabbi of 19th or early 20th century Tunisian Jewry and that the song praises him and his spiritual powers. Ilana is a woman’s name, but I have no idea what role, if any she plays in this song.

Prof. Edwin Seroussi, a musicologist and director of the Jewish Music Research Center at the Hebrew University has confirmed that the song is sung in Judeo-Arabic. The language is spoken by North African Jews. Its companion language, Ladino (Judeo-Spanish) is spoken by Jews whose origins are in Spain, and the countries to which Spanish Jews fled after 1492.
Ya Ilana-Rabbi Nessim (hear it) is a spirited duet between adult and child male voices accompanied by the oud and rhythmic hand claps. The child’s voice in particular is utterly charming. The boy sings with great gusto and passion and the oud accompaniment ornaments and embellishes the singing beautifully. Perhaps one of our Sephardic listeners can tell me more about this song!
Alain Scetbon
Haggada de Pessah (Ness Music)
Ya Ilana-Rabbi Nessim (3:34)

Crazy Flower: A Collection
10. Chava Albertstein is perhaps Israel’s greatest female vocalist in the European chanteuse tradition. In Chad Gadya (hear it), she slyly transforms a Passover children’s song extolling God’s omnipotence into an indictment of the Israeli occupation:

On all nights, all other nights I asked only Four Questions 
This night I have another question: 
“How long will the cycle of violence continue?” 
Chase and be chased, beat and be beaten, 
When will this madness end?
How have you changed, how are you different? 
I changed this year. 
I was once a sheep and a tranquil kid 
Today I’m a tiger and a ravening wolf 
I was once a dove and I was a deer. Today I don’t know who I am.

5:04 Chad Gadya
Chava Alberstein

Ballad of Mauthausen

11. The Ballad of Mauthausen was a book by Iacovos Kambanellis, a survivor of the concentration camp. He persuaded his friend, Mikis Theodorakis to write a musical suite of the same name and both works were published in 1965. They are both screams of protest against the evil of Nazi tyranny and loving memories of the victims in their suffering. Asma Asmaton (hear it), Greek for Song of Songs, is at once a composition of immense grace and pain. You can hear the both the pride and resistance in the Maria Farantouri’s powerful voice as she sings of the victims’ fate:

Beyond the bleak and frozen square / Above the yellow linen star / No heart will ever beat again / Because the beautiful have lost their way to paradise….

Mikis Theodorakis
Ballad of Mauthausen
Asma Asmaton (6:30Page 5 of 6)

Conclusion:

For those of our listeners used to thinking of Jews as only living in America or perhaps Israel, it may come as a surprise that there have been Jewish communities almost everywhere where there has been commerce including in North Africa, India, China, Latin America, Arabia and central Asia. I’ve tried my best to rustle up some music from these far away places to give you a taste of how Jewish music sounds there.

There is Jewish live and recorded music in Seattle though you may have to look hard to find it. You’ll find recordings at the Tree of Life Bookstore on 65th Avenue in Wedgwood). Wendy Marcus led a wonderful klezmer band called the Mazeltones whose records are still available online. She now leads a children’s klezmer band affiliated with Temple Beth Am called Klez Kids. And for Sephardic music and culture, there are Congregations Bikur Holim and Ezra Besoroth in Seward Park.

To find the original posts about these recordings published in this blog search on Passover Music.

Save a Life–Do a Bone Marrow Donor Test

Monday, March 26th, 2007

Someone posted this in a comment thread here and I thought it worthy to turn it into a post in its own right. I have had a bone marrow donor test done already and I recommend anyone who hasn’t to have it done. You could give the blessing of life to someone and perform a great mitzvah. Here is the announcement:

Zichron Menachem Bone Marrow Drive – Dafna
March 08, 2007
Dafna, a mother of 3, is fighting for her life. Bone marrow transplantation could save her. Nowadays, a simple saliva test could help determine the compatibility of potential bone marrow donors. Time is running out for Dafna, a mother of three young children, who must undergo Bone Marrow Transplantation (BMT) to stay alive. Please help us fund the tests necessary to save the life of Dafna and many more cancer patients awaiting BMT. Please take this opportunity to help save a life.
All saliva samples are to be stored in a database, which would be used to save the lives of over 120,000 Cancer patients in Israel.

For further details call (212) 594-6996 or e-mail mickyw@zichron.org

Brought to you by The Children’s Bridge of Zichron Menachem, Inc., together with the Hadassa Hospital and Am Israel Chai. All are non-profit organizations.

http://www.zichron.org.

In Need of Kidney Transplant
February 07, 2007
Dear Members of the U.S. Jewish Community,

A member of the Jewish community of the greater Washington, D.C. area has just discovered that she is in dire need of a kidney transplant due to a sudden diagnosis of end-stage kidney disease. Her condition is caused by the same rare disease that affected Alonzo Mourning (the basketball player). Anyone with Type B+ or O+ blood who would consider this procedure would be greatly appreciated. For the donor the surgery is done laparoscopically with minimal scarring and recovery time. All of the donors’ medical costs as well any incidental expenses including loss of income will be covered.

All interested parties should call Eloida Gonzalez, the transplant coordinator at Washington Hospital Center at 1-800-252-2442 or 202-877-9035. She will be happy to discuss the entire protocol and arrange the required testing for interested parties.

All inquiries will be kept strictly confidential.

Please reference patient C. Segal.

Thank you so much for considering this and passing along this message to the other communities in your lives so that we can spread this word as widely as possible. Her optimal chances for success involve finding a donor within the next two months

Fighting the Spanish Civil War All Over Again

Saturday, March 24th, 2007


Edward Rothstein and Ronald Radosh have reviewed, in the NY Times and NY Sun respectively, the history exhibition, Facing Fascism, which recently opened at the Museum of the City of New York. The exhibit chronicles the participation of New York City youth in that opening salvo of World War II, the Spanish Civil War.

In their reviews (Rothstein in a milder, and Radosh a more virulent form), it seems, they are attempting to refight the battles of the Civil War itself and the subsequent Cold War. Though I have not yet seen the exhibition (I will be in NYC shortly and will try to see it then), it seems that Rothstein-Radosh may have at least one valid criticism. They contend that the curators and funders of the exhibit have engaged in hagiography toward the Abraham Lincoln Brigades. They believe that making martyrs and heroes out of these fighters masks the nefarious activities of the Soviet Union during the War and its efforts to turn the Royalist forces and Spain itself into a totalitarian Soviet Republic. The evidence they present of Soviet manipulation of the International Brigade volunteers is persuasive. It may be true that the motives of the Communists were as suspect as the Francoists.

However, there is one major problem with the Radosh argument that the Soviets would have been as bad or worse than the Francoists. We’ll never know because Franco won and the Royalists didn’t. We know how evil Franco was because he had the opportunity to realize his viciousness in power. We know much less about how a Royalist government would have operated.

Rothstein seriously understates the scale of Franco’s evil in this passage:

Franco was indeed a ruthless tyrant whose victory led to wide-scale purges, cruel imprisonments and extensive constraints.

For “purges” read wholesale murder of thousands of political opponents. “Extensive constraints?” Is that all? Four decades of tyranny and the best you can muster is this?

As for Radosh, his biases are a mile wide and a mile deep. We should note that he is affiliated with the Hudson Institute, one of the leading neocon think tanks. The article is published in the Sun, the leading Neocon newspaper. And while there are serious arguments worth grappling with in his review, the fact that the Lincoln Brigade was not actually a “brigade” but a “battalion” is certainly not one of them. He is so intent on proving the perfidy of the CPUSA that he must use even this obscure angel dancing on the head of a pin to make his argument.

What is most noxious about Radosh’s perspective is the complete absence, except as a bit player, of Franco from his discussion. The evil is all on the Communist side. Royalists and Lincoln Brigade members are at best dupes and at worst malevolent bullies on the make. No mention of Franco the tyrant, fascism, the alliance with Hitler and Mussolini, Spain’s forty years of abject penury and tyranny at the hands of Spain’s fascists. This is a fatal and unforgivable omission on Radosh’s part which sullies whatever else he might have to say.

milt wolff spanish civil war fighterMilt Wolff during the Spanish Civil War (credit: Wolff homepage)

In the rush to indict the Brigade before the bar of history, Radosh also distorts the record of a fighter I actually knew, Milt Wolff. When I was a grad student at UC Berkeley in the 1980s, I attended a weekly writer’s workshop held at Milt’s home. He was a dynamic, funny and affable fellow with a clear spark of energy and wit about him. I knew he was a Spanish Civil War veteran and that he’d later served in the War. Only later would I learn that he’d also been an officer in the O.S.S., the WWII-era precursor to the CIA.

Knowing all this, you may put the following into better perspective than Radosh does:

Wolff gave [a speech] to the Lincoln vets’ convention in 1941, two years after the pact was signed, but before it expired:

Under the dishonest slogan of anti-fascism, [President Roosevelt] prepares the red-baiting, unionbusting, alien-hunting, anti-Negro, anti-Semitic Jingoistic road to fascism in America … he drags the American people … closer and closer to open participation in the imperialist slaughter in which the youth of our country will, if he has his way, join the … bloody and bloated corpses on the battlefields the world over; for the greater glory of foreign trade and the brutal oppression of free people at home and abroad; we accuse him, Franklin Demagogue Roosevelt. … We fight against the involvement of our country in an imperialist war. … We stubbornly oppose every move of Roosevelt and the war-mongers.

Radosh attempts to make Wolff out to be an automaton in the service of Communist propaganda. Admittedly, this speech reads pretty poorly in the light of historical events. Hopefully, it wouldn’t have been one I would’ve made or agreed with if I were alive then.

But Radosh neglects to point out that Wolff changed his mind and fought admirably for his country. The neocon historian would no doubt cynically point out that Wolff waited to fight until the German-Soviet pact collapsed and the Russians declared Hitler public enemy number 1. But the truth is that Radosh leaves out all reference to Wolff’s World War II military service. This is another unpardonable omission.

Finally, whether or not the idealism of those who fought in the Brigades was attenuated by the behavior of the Soviet Union I believe these young men who fought and died to stop fascism deserve our admiration. Certainly, we ought to know about the background to their sacrifice and service and use it to place everything else in proper perspective. But no belittling historian like Radosh can succeed at tarnishing their record using such deeply ideologically tainted and tendentious arguments.

Will U.S. Finally Get a Mideast Policy?

Saturday, March 24th, 2007

Lots of unintentional humor of a dark kind in today’s NY Times article, Rice Hints at U.S. Peace Push on Mideast. It’s the type of article that unfortunately reinforces just how dim U.S. policy is toward the Israeli-Arab conflict. First, surprise, surprise, after campaigning on a promise of never trying to impose U.S. will or solutions on the parties to the conflict and spending the last six years coasting on a policy of do-nothingness, Condi Rice has decided that well, maybe she needs to pull a Bill Clinton and actually come up with some creative ideas to move the parties forward:

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice has opened the door to the possibility that the United States might offer its own proposals to bridge the divide on some of the issues that have bedeviled the region since 1979.

“I don’t rule out at some point that might be a useful thing to do,” Ms. Rice told reporters in Washington before departing for Aswan, Egypt.

Of course, trying to impose an American-made solution on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has, for years, been the very thing that Bush administration officials have steadfastly said they would not do.

But times have changed.

Indeed. Iraq in full civil war mode. Gazans starving. Israelis wallowing in scandal and post-war malaise. Bush’s presidency in the toilet. What can she lose? But just think if she had come to this realization when Bush actually had some of that famous political capital he promised to invest in resolving this conflict. Come to think of it–don’t think of that. It’s enough to make you weep.

Here’s more of what I call “Boker tov” (which could roughly be translated as “gee, dya think??”) policy wonk moments:

Several State Department officials say that there is now an acknowledgment within the administration that the hands-off policy has caused prospects for peace to deteriorate.

“This is a place where if you leave things alone, they don’t just stagnate,” one administration official said. “They get worse.”

Ms. Rice has been pushing for openings even as multiple doors have appeared to slam shut.

It took them six years to realize this?

In Egypt this weekend, Ms. Rice is expected to try to prod America’s Sunni Arab allies to augment a 2002 Saudi peace proposal when the Arab League holds its meeting in Riyadh at the end of the month. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon of the United Nations, who is on his own tour of the Middle East, will also be there.

American officials have largely given up their hope that the Arabs might actually change the initiative to include things more palatable to Israel — like, for instance, signaling a willingness to at least discuss ways to settle the issue of Palestinian refugees who left, or were forced to leave, their homes in Israel.

But Ms. Rice may be able to get some sort of formal or informal mechanism going that could give the Israelis the hope of eventually normalizing relations with the Arab world, American officials said. “It would be a very good thing if at some point, the Arab initiative provided a basis for discussion,” Ms. Rice said.

This is all so hopelessly vague and even unnecessary. Why in God’s name do you try to tinker with a pre-negotiation proposal when that’s what you’re supposed to do during actual negotiations? It reminds me of the days of Bobby Fisher when he used to bargain endlessly on the most minute rules of the chess match before he even sat down to play. I say, play the game. Stop trying to change the rules for the negotiation and just negotiate. In fact, the very notion that the rules of talking must suit you fully BEFORE you talk is a way to prevent anyone FROM talking. Rice is still playing the Israeli game here. And that is a sure sign of a hopeless outcome even before she’s starting.

There’s this new meme reflected here and in Tom Friedman’s last column (TimesSelect required) that the onus is now on Saudi Arabia to carry water for the U.S. in brokering Arab consensus to make peace with Israel. I’m sorry but it just doesn’t work that way. This is just an acknowledgment that the U.S. is so hopelessly biased in favor of Israel that it can’t possibly serve any useful or honest broker role between the sides. That leaves it to the Saudi king to lay his entire prestige on the line on behalf of peace. The Saudis have always been loathe to bet the house when there is so much to lose. And besides, relying on them so completely is yet another sign of the weakness of our own position.

I always like hearing from David Makovsky on the Israel-Palestine conflict. He always has something relatively innocuous and useless to say that reflects hopelessly pro-Israel prejudices. Here he doesn’t disappoint:

“We’re at a critical juncture right now,” said David Makovsky, a Middle East specialist with the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. “The Arab states can reach out to the Israeli center, and to Olmert,” who Mr. Makovsky pointed out is politically weakened right now within Israel. “But if they don’t, they shouldn’t be surprised if Israel moves rightward.”

Oh, you mean the Arabs should be shivering in their boots at the prospect that if they don’t make their best deal with that well-known “centrist” Olmert that Netanyahu is in the wings? And this is supposed to intimidate them? Look, they’ve lived through Netanyahu, Shamir and Sharon before. Israeli right wing ogres just don’t intimidate like they used to especially after Israel’s shellacking in Lebanon.

I say boys and girls, get down to talking before it’s too late for both of your sides.